On the one hand it’s grotesque that they did this. On the other hand it’s good that they’re not defending it and they are fixing it.
One stone at a time.
Updating to include action tweet:
https://twitter.com/MidwivesRCM/status/1466345898569576448… Read the restlol
https://twitter.com/hatpinwoman/status/1466451219346505730… Read the restDOCTOR Adrian Harrop wasted no time after the GMC let him off with a one month suspension yesterday, he immediately spilled his guts to fellow fanatic Ben Hunte at VICE to explain again how saintly he is and how evil the women who disagree with him are.
The headline sneers at the idea that Harrop’s tweets were anything other than perfectly reasonable and polite:
‘Humiliated but Determined’: Pro-Trans UK Doctor Suspended for ‘Insulting’ Tweets
Because they weren’t insulting, you see. They were fine! Helpful! Polite!
Adrian Harrop will be suspended for a month after sending “offensive” tweets to people who opposed his views on trans rights.
Because they weren’t offensive, you see. Only a monster would say they were.
… Read the restA
Innnnteresting.
*Breaking*
I'm hearing tonight that Surrey County Council are officially withdrawing from Stonewall. Not just waiting for membership to lapse – actually leaving according to a public Q&A by SCC leader Tim Oliver.
The wall is coming down people
— Dennis Noel Kavanagh (@Jebadoo2) December 1, 2021
It doesn’t tell us anything we don’t know, but it’s good to see it in an actual news outlet, with a mug shot.
Smug git; steer clear.… Read the rest
Won’t somebody please think of the harrop.
https://twitter.com/CF_Farrow/status/1465810466601586688Why should the women DOCTOR Harrop tormented care about allowing him to “move forward”? Why should they do what the GMC asks when the GMC did nothing to stop him tormenting women for years?… Read the rest
Science museum makes changes at the behest of science-denying loonies.
The Science Museum is set to alter its Boy or Girl? display following complaints over a “lack of mention of transgender”.
The museum in question is the science museum, just as it says in the name, the one in South Kensington, inspired by Dear Albert in the wake of the Great Exhibition. It matters, the way the one on Central Park West matters.
Curators will make changes to a gallery covering human biology in order to “update (the) non inclusive narrative”, it can be revealed.
But science has nothing to do with being “inclusive” at the expense of being accurate. Science isn’t a club or a gang or a … Read the rest
The Supreme Court knows who is a woman and who isn’t. Women are those people the government gets to force to bear children against their will. Women are those people who can’t make their own decisions about their own lives. Women are those people whose bodies belong to the state.
… Read the restUntil now, all the court’s abortion decisions have upheld Roe‘s central framework — that women have a constitutional right to an abortion in the first two trimesters of pregnancy when a fetus is unable to survive outside the womb, until roughly between 22 and 24 weeks.
But Mississippi’s law bans abortion after 15 weeks. A separate law enacted a year later would ban abortions after six weeks, and while
So I searched the posts archive and found the last time I had occasion to mention Matt Dillahunty: it was in February and March 2018 and it was about the fact that he and Sam Harris were booked to do an event with Lawrence Krauss despite accusations of sexual harassment against Krauss.
It makes me tired all over again, just reading the posts. The whole idea of going anywhere – even from one room to another – to listen to those three wowing us with their giant male brains makes me want to hibernate. The one from February says why:
… Read the restI suppose this is a built-in hazard of having these all-male Celebrations of All the Brain Things That Women Can’t
The ego-dogmatism soup here is something to behold.
Biologically female isn't relevant to being a woman.
— Matt Dillahunty (@Matt_Dillahunty) November 29, 2021
Loud domineering guy tells the world that being biologically female isn’t relevant to being a woman. Not his to give away, yet again.
https://twitter.com/wwwritingclub/status/1466008583385006085Correct. And?
— Matt Dillahunty (@Matt_Dillahunty) November 30, 2021
And, those people who have wombs, those people without whom none of us would exist, are women. That’s the word for them. If the Matt Dillahuntys and Adrian Harrops succeed in their efforts to make that word not mean “the ones with wombs” then we’ll just have to get a new word which will mean the same thing. What’s the point of that? We … Read the rest
We’re not the ones who have “bought into the confusion.”
I'm sorry that you've bought into the fear mongering and confusion. Trans-women are women. Period.
Nothing about this is REMOTELY like believing in bread transforming to the literal body of christ. Trans people aren't claiming to be Cis. THAT would fit your analogy.
— Matt Dillahunty (@Matt_Dillahunty) November 30, 2021
A stupid counter-factual assertion doesn’t become less stupid or less counter-factual because you add a “Period” to it. Matt Dillahunty is Lauren Boebert’s second-best espresso machine. Period. See? It doesn’t work. Trans women are men who say they feel like women inside. That’s what “trans women” means. It’s the word “women” that means “women”; the phrase “trans women” means something … Read the rest
Harrop was worse than I knew. Graham Linehan and ripx4nutmeg share some revolting details of what he and Stephanie Hayden did to Caroline Farrow:
Not your average caring GP.
Caroline’s husband is a Catholic priest at two parishes and in 2019 Harrop asked Stephanie Hayden for a game of golf, using a picture of one of her husband’s churches. Hayden famously has a conviction for attacking a man with a golf club.
Taunts and “jokes” that went on and on, and more. Targeted sadistic relentless harassment of a woman he disagrees with over trans dogma. One month really doesn’t seem like enough after reading all that. (The worst harassment shown here was by someone else, but Harrop’s was only … Read the rest
The BBC picks up a very long pair of tongs to talk about [whispers] hijab.
Europe’s top human rights organisation has pulled posters from a campaign that promoted respect for Muslim women who choose to wear headscarves after provoking opposition in France.
See it? The very long pair of tongs? It’s the “choose to” bit. It’s tendentious to talk about Muslim women “choosing to” wear hijab when in fact women are forced to wear it, and tortured or even killed for refusing to wear it, in many places where Islam has not liberalized even slightly.
It’s probably the case that many Muslim women in Europe do have a choice, but it’s also well known that many of them don’t… Read the rest
A Stonewall spokesperson said: “It is not true that Stonewall looks to shut down debate. Meaningful, constructive debate and discussion around complex policy ideas are at the heart of what we do as a charity. The one thing we do not debate is whether trans people exist. They do, and what we need to discuss is how to make a world where all LGBTQ+ are free to be themselves.”
Even if it’s true that Stonewall doesn’t look to shut down debate, it sure as hell does muddy it. That spokesperson spokement is some very wet sloppy mud.
Nobody is saying “trans people don’t exist.” That’s not the issue at all. We all know there … Read the rest
Such a nice man, and (as he doesn’t mind saying himself) such a feminist.
You mean the people who called out her transphobic remarks? I call them "correct".
There is no canceling, just accountability.
— Matt Dillahunty (@Matt_Dillahunty) November 29, 2021
Biologically female isn't relevant to being a woman.
— Matt Dillahunty (@Matt_Dillahunty) November 29, 2021
Huh. Tell that to a woman giving birth. Tell it to a woman in her 35th week of pregnancy. Tell it to a woman who’s been raped. Tell it to the women who lost medals to Veronica Ivy and Laurel Hubbard. Tell it, as another person on Twitter said to him, to the Taliban.… Read the rest
So as you’ve seen Harrop received a one month suspension.
Decision was handed down privately – 1 month suspension.
— Tribunal Tweets (@tribunaltweets) November 30, 2021
That sounds like nothing but word is it’s not. It’s on his record and will limit his career from now on.
2/ Suspensions are generally rare and this will have an effect on career prospects / insurance and reputation.
It's not the sort of thing anyone with any sense would celebrate as an outcome.
— Dennis Noel Kavanagh (@Jebadoo2) November 30, 2021
It’s on the record that he engaged in inappropriate, insulting and at times intimidatory communications on Twitter – in short that he’s a bully. … Read the rest
There’s an odd thing about Matt Dillahunty’s trans dogma though.
I'm sorry for you. Because I am smart, sassy and clear sighted – I'm just not a bigot and I'm able to tell the difference between biological sex and gender, which is a social construct.
My critical faculties are fine, thank you.
— Matt Dillahunty (@Matt_Dillahunty) November 30, 2021
Ok so trans women are women in the sense of having (or being or living or some other verb) female gender, but not in the sense of being of the female sex. But in that case, what makes it ok for trans women “to access spaces where women and girls are undressing, such as changing rooms?” How does gender, a … Read the rest
From the Shut Up I Win files:
https://twitter.com/FemmeLoves/status/1465492195901906947 https://twitter.com/FemmeLoves/status/1465489711825408003 https://twitter.com/FemmeLoves/status/1465505512334708736I feel lucky that I never wasted any admiration on Matt Dillahunty. Never listened to the podcast, only ever heard him speak once, at the American Atheists jamboree in Austin, and found him obnoxiously macho-loud and overbearing. Stamped CONFIRMED.… Read the rest
Originally a comment by Der Durchwanderer on All the rights.
There is only one trans “right” being asserted by activists, and that is the “right” to have everyone else in the world affirm their particular religious beliefs, at all times and in all places.
The incoming government of Germany has recently signed an agreement in principle on their governing priorities, which must now be referred to the coalition parties at large for approval before that government can be put into effect. When the agreement is approved, the measures within it will not automatically become law, but they provide a roadmap for what the government wishes to accomplish during its reign.
Many of the proposals are undoubtedly an improvement over … Read the rest
The stars of Activism are really on fire today. Not entirely in a good sense.
https://twitter.com/KatyMontgomerie/status/1465392439322103823Spaces set aside for other people aren’t a “right.” Puberty blockers and elective amputations aren’t “health care.” “Legal protections” that endanger other people aren’t “protections.”
He summoned the troops.
https://twitter.com/KatyMontgomerie/status/1465397550287106049Well, really snarky, at least.… Read the rest
