All entries by this author
Mar 12th, 2022 4:12 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
No, Waterstones. That’s not correct.
Not period. Not end of story. Not true. Being a woman isn’t subjective – note that “identifying as” something is entirely subjective and self-reported and thus not something that anyone else can confirm or deny. Being a woman isn’t like that. Vladimir Putin could identify as a woman; it wouldn’t make him one.
And that arrogant bullying claim not only has nothing to do with feminism, it’s an insult to feminism – so what’s it doing on a table with a “Feminism” sign at Waterstones Norwich? Besides … Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
1 Comment »
Mar 12th, 2022 9:07 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Does the law actually say trans women are women?
No.
This is a relief to me, because really, who gave the law authority to determine ontology? That would just be weird. The law can define categories for the purpose of a law, but it can’t just bang a gavel and say strawberries are luxury automobiles.
Naomi Cunningham at Legal Feminist spelled it out a couple of years ago:
The Gender Recognition Act 2004 does change some people’s legal sex. Obviously the law can’t change anyone’s biological sex. The fact that the law can’t mess with material reality is the point Canute was making when he forbade the tide to come in. But section 9 of the Gender Recognition Act 2004
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
2 comments
Mar 12th, 2022 8:40 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Keir Starmer throws women overboard.
Asked to define a woman, Starmer replied: “A woman is a female adult, and in addition to that trans women are women, and that is not just my view — that is actually the law. It has been the law through the combined effects of the 2004 [Gender Recognition] Act and the 2010 [Equality] Act. So that’s my view. It also happens to be the law in the United Kingdom.”
It doesn’t “happen to be” the law, it’s a law because people have lost their fucking minds.
You can’t turn men into women by passing laws. You can change definitions under law, but you can’t change the underlying reality. If you want to pass … Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
6 comments
Mar 12th, 2022 7:43 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Sarah Ditum on Labour’s inability to say what the word “woman” means:
Clearly, asking a Labour MP to define “woman” is a reliable way to get them to look silly. And so interviewers are going to keep on doing it. Which means that Labour should, at some point in the past two years, have come up with a one-line answer, if only to get them through media appearances.
…
Because, despite Cooper’s dismissive attitude, the definition of “woman” does matter. It matters for single-sex spaces. It matters for sport. It matters for the language we use to talk about female health. It matters for measuring the income gap, and for monitoring who’s doing more than their fair share of
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
1 Comment »
Mar 11th, 2022 5:29 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Carol Tavris wrote a few weeks ago about the fad for transing and the failure of much of journalism to report on it fully.
An August 6, 2021 episode of WNYC’s “On the Media” illustrates the problem: the hosts focused on efforts “to block access to medical care for trans kids,” the “politics and propaganda behind the recent wave of anti-trans legislation,” and “what the science tells us about gender affirming care in adolescence.” But “On the Media” did not tell the full story. The usually thorough reporters did not invite a cultural historian to wonder why “gender affirming” clinics have proliferated, from only one in 2010 to more than 400 today, offering puberty blockers and hormones to facilitate
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
9 comments
Mar 11th, 2022 12:15 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
James Kirkup at the Spectator says it’s a difficult time to be a girl:
In 2019, the Lancet published research showing girls’ rates of self-harm had tripled since 2000. Other studies show girls are much more likely to be depressed or anxious than boys.
I would hate to be a girl in this climate. Porn, “sex work,” giant testosterone-filled “girls” taking all the good parts – no thank you.
On the surface things look pretty encouraging.
They’re more likely than boys to go to university. They have better economic prospects than any generation of females that went before them. Empowered female role models are more visible than ever before, in culture, sport, media, science, business, even politics.
Yet at
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
4 comments
Mar 11th, 2022 11:24 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Oh my god Raif is out of prison.
Saudi blogger Raif Badawi – jailed and sentenced to 1,000 lashes for “insulting Islam online” – has been freed, his wife says.
“Raif called me. He is free,” Ensaf Haidar told AFP news agency from Canada, where she fled with the couple’s three children.
The blogger’s first 50 lashes caused a global outcry and he became an emblem of rights abuses in the country.
There has been no official Saudi comment on his release.
Mr Badawi’s son Terad also tweeted: “My father is free.”
But he’s still under a travel ban.
The NGO Reporters Without Borders said it would work to ensure he can join his family in Canada despite the
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
2 comments
Mar 11th, 2022 10:54 am |
By Ophelia Benson
W. H. Auden wrote a poem titled August 1968 in the wake of the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia to suppress the Prague Spring.
The Ogre does what ogres can,
Deeds quite impossible for Man,
But one prize is beyond his reach:
The Ogre cannot master Speech.
About a subjugated plain,
Among the desperate and slain,
The Ogre stalks with hands on hips,
While drivel gushes from his lips.
Cody Walker wrote at Kenyon Review in September 2016:
We depend on poets for this kind of expression, of course. A totalitarian regime communicates through jargon and claptrap; a poet (or a poet like Auden, anyway) fires back with rhyme and tetrameter. At the time, the fight doesn’t feel fair—but history
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
1 Comment »
Mar 11th, 2022 9:05 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Anna asked in a comment:
Have you seen the pro-Nazi Azov battalion?
I hope this doesn’t turn out like when we helped the Afghanistans against the Russians in the 1980s and then some of them turned out to be terrorists.
Snopes on the Azov Battalion:
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the ensuing military violence and instability have mobilized far-right extremists, playing into Russian President Vladimir Putin’s propaganda about “neo-Nazis” running the country as justification for invading Ukraine.
In a speech given just before Russia launched its ongoing attack on Ukraine, Putin justified what he described as a “special military operation.” He stated:
Its goal is to protect people who have been abused by the genocide of the Kyiv
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
3 comments
Mar 11th, 2022 8:15 am |
By Ophelia Benson
I saw this –
– so I stared a bit, trying to recall ever seeing any ads for “kill the racist” or “kill the homophobe” shirts, and then I Googled “official kill the terf shirt” and found, depressingly, that it’s not just the one company.
Then I Googled “official kill the racist shirt” and found…no match.… Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
7 comments
Mar 11th, 2022 6:01 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Masha Gessen tells us that Russians don’t know what’s happening, because they don’t have access to truthful reporting.
A majority of Russians get their news from broadcast television, which is fully controlled by the state. “This is largely a country of older people and poor people,” Lev Gudkov told me. Gudkov is the director of the Levada Center, which was once Russia’s leading public-opinion-research organization and which the state has now branded a “foreign agent.” There are more Russians over the age of forty-five than there are between the ages of fifteen and forty-four. Even those who get their news online are still unlikely to encounter a narrative that differs from what broadcast television offers. The state continues to ratchet
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
6 comments
Mar 10th, 2022 3:37 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Another ACLU ad on Facebook.
An anonymous donor has pledged to match all donations up to $200,000. Every dollar you donate right now will be doubled and immediately put towards our legal, advocacy, and organizing work that supports trans kids and their families.
“Supports” how though? What do they mean by support?
They’re “supporting” what they call “trans kids” by working to make sure they can get drastic, irreversible surgery or drugs or both. It’s not as clear-cut as they think that that equals “support.” It could be that the reality is that some or all such “kids” are caught up in a trend, and will regret this medical tampering with their path to physical adulthood. In addition to everything … Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
18 comments
Mar 10th, 2022 11:52 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Culture war:
Culture has long been a proxy in the assertion of power by one people over another. Recent egregious examples include the Chinese government’s attempt to suppress Uyghur religion, literature, music, even food, and Islamic State’s destruction of ancient monuments. In war, culture is a second front. At their most extreme, wars are about eradicating a people’s cultural memory altogether, wiping them from the slate as if they had never been.
…
In some ways, intentions are less important than effects, amid war’s messy reality. A missile strike in Kyiv that reportedly killed five people was seemingly directed at the television tower, but it lies close to Babyn Yar, the site of the massacre of 150,000 people
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
2 comments
Mar 10th, 2022 10:48 am |
By Ophelia Benson
One good thing:
A virtual gallery to showcase Mali’s cultural history has been launched, featuring tens of thousands of Timbuktu’s ancient manuscripts.
The manuscripts were smuggled to safety from Timbuktu after Islamist militant groups took control of the city in northern Mali in 2012.
They contain centuries of African knowledge and scholarship on topics ranging from maths to astrological charts.
“Central to the heritage of Mali, they represent the long legacy of written knowledge and academic excellence in Africa,” said Dr Abdel Kader Haidara, a librarian known for smuggling the manuscripts out of Timbuktu, who was also involved in the project.
The site is called Mali Magic and from a quick look it is pretty damn magic. It’s music … Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
3 comments
Mar 10th, 2022 7:01 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Chip chip chip chip away.
It’s not young people. Boys don’t miss school because of period poverty.
Say the word. The word is “girls.” It’s not blasphemy or porn; we can say it. Girls.
To be fair, they do know how to say it.
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
9 comments