All entries by this author

Jeremy Waldron on Incoherent Ideas of Free Speech *

Jul 17th, 2006 | Filed by

Nazis can disrupt the streets of Skokie, but those who disrupt Rumsfeld’s message will be dragged away. … Read the rest



Kent Hovind Busted on Federal Charges *

Jul 17th, 2006 | Filed by

Dr. Dino claims he is employed by God, receives no income, has no expenses and owns no property.… Read the rest



No Continuum Between Science and Non-science *

Jul 17th, 2006 | Filed by

You can’t practice methodological naturalism 99% of the time and still claim to be a scientist. … Read the rest



An Analogy That Isn’t

Jul 16th, 2006 10:26 pm | By

Here’s something I don’t get. Or maybe I do get it and just think it’s silly. One of those. It’s from an article by Michael Ruse in Robert Pennock’s collection Intelligent Design Creationism and its Critics, “Methodological Naturalism under Attack,” page 365. Ruse is making the distinction (which featured heavily in the Kitzmiller trial) between metaphysical naturalism and methodological naturalism; he’s making the distinction and explaining it and arguing for it.

This is not to say that God did not have a role in the creation, but simply that, qua science, that is qua an enterprise formed through the practice of methodological naturalism, science has no place for talk of God. Just as, for instance, if one were to

Read the rest


Atheists in America

Jul 16th, 2006 6:38 pm | By

Sometimes I think I should keep a suitcase packed at all times, ready to grab when I hear the sirens approaching.

Penny Edgell, Doug Hartmann and I published a paper in the American Sociological Review called “Atheists As ‘Other’: Moral Boundaries and Cultural Membership in American Society.” In a national survey, part of a broader project on multiculturalism and solidarity in American life that we call the American Mosaic Project, we found that one group stood out from all others in terms of the level of rejection they received from the general public. That was atheists. And not by a small margin, either.

That’s not in the least a surprise, but it’s a useful sharpening.

How does such a

Read the rest


Atheists as ‘Other’ *

Jul 16th, 2006 | Filed by

‘Atheists’ serves as catch-all word for ‘bad people.’… Read the rest



It’s ‘Crop Circle Season’ *

Jul 16th, 2006 | Filed by

Victoria Coren on alien holiday planning; James Randi comments.… Read the rest



Prayers Save People From Death *

Jul 16th, 2006 | Filed by

There was this guy who was very ill, see, and people prayed for him, and he didn’t die. So.… Read the rest



Nick Cohen on the Selling of Honours *

Jul 16th, 2006 | Filed by

Honours Act says you can’t buy them, you can’t sell them and if you do either you can go to prison.… Read the rest



Sarfraz Manzoor on ‘Faith Schools’ *

Jul 16th, 2006 | Filed by

‘How do we avoid, in Trevor Phillips’s phrase, sleepwalking into segregation?’… Read the rest



Wonkette, Phooey

Jul 16th, 2006 2:53 am | By

Okay, what’s the deal here? I thought Ana Marie Cox was supposed to be so clever, or witty or interesting or something – ? Isn’t she? I thought she was. I’ve never read or even glanced at Wonkette, because life is short and time is scarce and blogs are many and the subject matter – beltway gossip? Urrgghh – is so very unappealing; but I’ve gathered (how? I don’t know – as one does) that she’s good in some way. But clearly there has been some mistake. That “book review” is a piece of crap; it’s stupid and smug and truly staggeringly predictable. So if that’s Wonkette, I’m glad I’ve never wasted so much as a nanosecond on it.… Read the rest



Nussbaum Reads MacKinnon

Jul 16th, 2006 2:15 am | By

Martha Nussbaum’s review of Catherine MacKinnon’s Are Women Human? ties in well with Danny Postel’s interview of Fred Halliday. Both put rights at the center – and in fact, as I noted in ‘Fred Halliday Rocks,’ Halliday cites Nussbaum (and Sen) on the subject. I would so much rather read Sen or Nussbaum or Appiah than Andrew Murray or Faisal Bodi or Inayat Bunglawala.

Inequality on the basis of sex is a pervasive reality of women’s lives all over the world. So is sex-related violence…Despite the prevalence of these crimes, they have not been well addressed under international human rights law…Until recently, abuses like rape and sexual torture lacked good human rights standards because human rights norms were typically

Read the rest


Fred Halliday Rocks

Jul 15th, 2006 9:16 pm | By

This is a stirring piece.

Fred Halliday: My view is that the kind of position which the New Left Review and Tariq have adopted in terms of the conflict in the Middle East is an extremely reactionary, right-wing one. It starts with Afghanistan. To my mind, Afghanistan is central to the history of the Left, and to the history of the world, since the 1980s. It is to the early 21st century, to the years we’re now living through, what the Spanish Civil War was to Europe in the mid and late 20th century…The issue of rights is absolutely central. We have to hold the line at the defense, however one conceptualizes things, however de-hegemonized, of universal principles of

Read the rest


The Religious Right and the HPV *

Jul 15th, 2006 | Filed by

Being pro-cancer is a little tricky for people who claim to be ‘pro-life.’… Read the rest



Stupid Cliché-ridden Review *

Jul 15th, 2006 | Filed by

Starts off with ‘strident feminism’ then cites bra-burners. Oy.… Read the rest



Katha Pollitt on the Joy of a Bad Review *

Jul 15th, 2006 | Filed by

Apparently there is such a thing as bad publicity: bad publicity that people don’t know about.… Read the rest



Martha Nussbaum on Catherine MacKinnon *

Jul 15th, 2006 | Filed by

Until recently, human rights norms were typically devised by men thinking about men’s lives.… Read the rest



The Issue of Rights is Absolutely Central *

Jul 15th, 2006 | Filed by

We have to hold the line at the defense, however de-hegemonized, of universal principles of rights.… Read the rest



Smile When You Call Me That

Jul 14th, 2006 5:50 pm | By

Hey I feel marginalized and neglected and I yearn – I yearn, I tell you, I yearn and burn and pine – to be understood as a community. Won’t someone please understand me as a community? It would make me so happy. Just once in awhile? On weekends maybe? Or during the World Cup?

Hindus…feel neglected and marginalised and yearn to be understood as a community…[They] do not want to be described as “Asian”, according to a big study of the community…The report, Connecting British Hindus, to be published in the Commons today, was funded by the Government and carried out by the Runnymede Trust and the Hindu Forum.

Connecting British Hindus. Connecting them to the community. The … Read the rest



Back Page

Jul 14th, 2006 5:20 pm | By

The Front Page ‘discussion’ with Norm and Nick is hilarious in a sad sort of way – sad if only because of the waste of time and effort and attention. Norm and Nick might as well have conversed with two nice four-foot lengths of solid brick wall, for all the good it did them.

Here’s FP’s Jamie Glazov starting things off, for instance:

The Left has a long, depressing, ugly and blood-stained record of worshipping the most vile and barbaric tyrannies of the 20th century, including Stalin’s Soviet Union, Mao’s China, Ho Chi Minh’s Vietnam and Castro’s Cuba…But if you are on the Left, are you not part of an ideology that holds that human redemption, accompanied by human equality

Read the rest