I kept going on arguing in that discussion at CfI yesterday, and in doing that I tried to boil down the point of contention to make it as clear as possible.
There are two possibilities for theists here.
1) There is a god who is transcendent, outside of nature, outside of the universe.
2) There is a god who is descendent, inside nature, inside the universe, and who makes things happen in our world.
There are different things to say about each. About 1, nearly everyone would agree that it’s not possible to offer evidence that such a god does not exist. But theists fail to draw the rest of the obvious conclusion: for the same reason that it’s not … Read the rest