Steven Pinker points out that New York Times book reviewer resorts to the very fallacy the book is about.… Read the rest
All entries by this author
Dignity and
Nov 4th, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonMystery, humility, human finitude; science has nothing to say about who we are; the self cannot be an illusion; free will must be true…Such are the platitudes that greet a book on bioethics by a presidential pundit.… Read the rest
Cleaning the closets
Nov 3rd, 2002 7:50 pm | By Ophelia BensonThere is a difference between amassing a great many facts, and acquiring or conveying knowledge or understanding. There is also a difference between exploring every possible detail and speculative possibility of Poet X’s sex life, and writing a good intellectual biography. The review of yet another new biography of Byron indicates that we have yet another example of the first part of the equation instead of the second. There has been a rash of such biographies in the last decade or so, profoundly anti-intellectual works that undertake to clean out the closets of various writers and thinkers without stopping to ask why we care about those closets if we don’t care about the work. We know more than we knew … Read the rest
Elitism or Meritocracy?
Nov 3rd, 2002 5:50 pm | By Ophelia BensonFrank Dobson, a Labour M.P. and former Secretary of State for Health, has an article in today’s Observer that assails the ‘elitist’ policies of Tony Blair’s government, particularly in education and health care. The health issue seems reasonably straightforward: he says that less money is being spent in poorer areas, and that does sound like a policy that favours the already favoured. But in education, surely things are not quite so simple. There is a worry, among those who agree with Dobson, about a proposal for super A-levels to challenge super-clever children. Dobson parses the idea this way:
… Read the rest“This idea that gifted children need super A-levels comes from people who want a privileged minority to be able to look down
Science Studies
Nov 2nd, 2002 | By Ophelia BensonIn 1994, Paul R. Gross and Norman Levitt published Higher Superstition,
and the pigeons have still not recovered from the shock of that particular cat.
Higher Superstition is a funny-painful ‘deconstruction’ or rather demolition
of an array of trendy anti-science ‘studies’, stances, branches of putative
scholarship: Postmodern, cultural constructivist, feminist, sociological, environmental.
Most of these orientations are on the left, although it has been frequently
pointed out (e.g. by Richard J. Evans in his article on Postmodern history on
this site) that PoMo is at least as useful to the right as it is to the left
and that there are indeed right-wing Postmodernists. But the majority of the
attacks on science come from the left (and could be … Read the rest
David Lodge thinks
Nov 2nd, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonWhich tells us more about consciousness, fiction or cognitive science?… Read the rest
Credentials
Nov 2nd, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonPhilosophers uncover conceptual connections and thus help to make ethical debate better informed.… Read the rest
Bizarre claims
Nov 2nd, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonPhilosophers will insist on getting Dawkins wrong.… Read the rest
Truth and lies
Nov 1st, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonBernard Williams defends the truth, while also exploring when we need to tell lies.… Read the rest
Anyone’s neighbour
Nov 1st, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia Benson‘It could be you’. Perhaps a more useful suggestion about the Nobel prize than about the lottery.… Read the rest
Tragic view
Nov 1st, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonAre John Gray and Steven Pinker saying the same dismal thing about human hopes, and are they right to be saying it?… Read the rest
Cargo cult science
Nov 1st, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia Benson‘Statistics show’ is a mere rhetorical device in education research, used to support whatever policy one favors. Research in cognitive psychology shows promise.… Read the rest
Mormon correctness
Oct 31st, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonEven practicing Mormons can have a hard time conforming to the rules at Brigham Young University.… Read the rest
One way to introduce the two cultures
Oct 31st, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonA computer scientist teaches liberal arts students an intelligent skepticism about computer technology…and what binary numbers are.… Read the rest
Where groupthink can lead
Oct 30th, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonThe Salem witch trials are interesting not because of the occult aspect but as an example of ‘senseless self-destruction’.… Read the rest
Oh, brilliant, pay the fun teachers more
Oct 30th, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonLink lecturers’ pay to how popular they are with students? Might there be some drawbacks to that idea? … Read the rest
Rorty on Williams on truth
Oct 30th, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonAre analytic philosophers ‘hard-working public relations agents for contemporary institutions and practices’? Or are neo-pragmatists hard-working Artful Dodgers…… Read the rest
Higher Superstition Revisited: an interview with Norman Levitt
Oct 30th, 2002 | By Ophelia BensonPaul R. Gross and Norman Levitt’s book Higher Superstition appeared
in 1994, rattled a good many cages, and prompted the Sokal Hoax. The book describes
a bizarre situation in American universities in which academics in various (mostly
new-minted) fields such as Cultural Studies, Literary Theory, and Science Studies,
plus a few more familiar ones such as Sociology, Comparative Literature and
the like, make a career of writing about science without taking the trouble
to know anything about it. Gross and Levitt have a good deal of fun exposing
the absurd mistakes perpetrated by people who rhapsodise about quantum mechanics
and chaos theory without having the faintest idea what they’re talking about.
But hilarity aside, there are serious issues involved. The … Read the rest
Oh, rapture
Oct 29th, 2002 3:40 pm | By Ophelia BensonTim LaHaye was on the US public radio show Fresh Air last night. He is a minister, a fundamentalist, a pillar of far-right politics, a former honcho in the Moral Majority, and…a best-selling novelist. To put it mildly. He is the co-author of a series which has sold (I cringe to relate) 50 million copies. The ‘left behind’ series. For those who have the good fortune not to know what on earth that is, the subject matter is ‘the Rapture’. You know. When Jesus shouts in the sky and all the believers are instantly taken up into heaven, to leave the rest of us down here to be tortured for all eternity (after a great deal of to-ing and fro-ing … Read the rest
Scientists were unpopular then too
Oct 29th, 2002 | Filed by Ophelia BensonEven in that supposed heyday of reason, attacks on freethinkers were a favourite sport.… Read the rest