Such neediness
[T]he 45th president of the US invited on stage a man who later revealed he has a 6ft cardboard model of his hero and talks to it every day.
Let’s just pause and think about that. This is a leader whose ego is so fragile, he wants to appear on stage with someone most of us would change seats to avoid if he sat next to us on a train. I should point out that Trump chose this particular supporter to appear beside him after he saw him being interviewed on TV before the rally. Ignoring the advice of his security officials: “He said, ‘I love Trump’ … Let him up. I’m not worried about him. I’m only worried he’s going to give me a kiss.”
It is an alarming insight into how Trump (though, not just Trump) operates. Few politicians, no matter how thin-skinned, have displayed such neediness nor demanded such displays of unconditional love from their supporters. Neediness is not usually considered attractive in men who like to be thought of as tough, but Trump is rewriting the rulebook on masculinity.
I’m not sure he’s rewriting that rulebook so much as he’s hiding it for the duration. I don’t think he’s going to establish a fashion for weird sculpted multi-directional dyed combovers, or for long flapping red neckties, or for talking through pooched lips like a goldfish.
Adulation is a dangerous drug for politicians, sometimes affecting those who should in theory be immune to it. Jeremy Corbyn spent years as an obscure Labour backbencher, and the transformation, when he unexpectedly found himself addressing adoring rallies during a couple of leadership contests, has been astonishing to behold.
Corbyn never looks more relaxed than when he arrives to address a theatre full of cheering supporters, coming alive on stage in a way he never does in TV interviews or at press conferences. He shares Trump’s irritation towards even mildly critical questions, instantly reverting to talking about his “mandate” in the same way that the president still boasts about how many votes he got in the electoral college.
This is as much about a type of masculinity – wounded, self-pitying, quick to anger – as it is right or left.
As much or more. I detest Trump as a human at least as much as I hate him politically.
I sometimes wonder if we couldn’t build a theme park where Trump is president for life, presiding in a replica Oval Office and flying in a pretend version of Air Force One that never actually leaves the ground. And I’m sure Corbyn would be happier in a fictional Labourland, holding as many Cuba Solidarity meetings as he likes, than leading the party into the next general election. We would have to pay for busloads of extras to provide cheering crowds, but it would be cheaper in the long run.
A horrible combination of circumstances – reality TV, distrust of politicians, a fightback against feminism – has landed us in this unenviable situation. The danger of treating politics as therapy for emotionally needy men is too enormous to allow it to last.
Emotionally needy and also furiously angry.
Loads of performers are like that. They need the applause and attention like oxygen. Fine for a rock star or actor of course, crappy for a politician.
That’s a good piece by Joan Smith about the neediness. Plenty of politicians like getting it of course – it shows that they’re popular – but don’t need it. I saw Michael Foot once looking downright embarrassed at a rally when Labour supporters were trying to kiss him, and although Nicola Sturgeon holds rallies & gets gangs of worshippers I don’t think she feeds upon it. It’s part of the job. Similarly Thatcher – got worship from her followers but didn’t feed upon it as was too busy enacting policies.
It’s creepy in both Trump & Corbyn.
I’m not sure I agree that neediness is unusual in men who like to see themselves as tough. The thing I’ve noticed is they like for everyone else to see them as tough, too. That’s neediness. I think John Wayne needed to be admired for his toughness; I think it is the constant need for admiration that leads to their swaggering bully natures.
Maybe we could ditch the flesh and blood Trump and install the cardboard one in his place. He’d probably be better on Twitter. And everything else.
And in case we ran out of newspaper, he’d be useful to start a fire in the fireplace.
@Your Name’s not Bruce?
We could take bets on how long it takes his fans to notice.
A cardboard cut out of someone _already_ barely two dimensional. I dunno. How doesn’t this run afoul of regulations prohibiting cloning?
To be fair, John Wayne started life as Marion. I can see him wanting to cultivate an image of toughness.