Different rules for different fools
Eva Kurilova draws up a partial list of the contradictions of trans ideology. There are so many and they are so contradictory.
“Trans women” are in danger in men’s spaces and that’s why they deserve access to women’s spaces.
Women who worry about their spaces becoming mixed sex are bigots.
…
Trans people are a very tiny minority and so they must be listened to.
Detransitioners are a very tiny minority and so they must not be listened to.
Gender is a social construct.
But “trans women” need to be treated as literally female in all aspects of life.
That’s a biggy, isn’t it. The biggy. Women are women via social convention, but trans women really are women and don’t you forget it.
If the perpetrator of a crime is a trans-identified man, he is reported as a woman.
If the victim of a crime is a trans-identified man, he is reported as a trans woman.
Oof. I hadn’t noticed that one.
Trans women make the covers of magazines for achievements in science, technology, and sports.
Trans men make the covers of magazines for being pregnant. Progress!
That one’s not so much a contradiction as a different rules problem.
Physical differences between men and women don’t matter in sports.
But “trans women” need to compete in the women’s category because HRT makes them weaker and disadvantaged against other men.
So much different rules problem.
Excellent list.
I’d add:
Gender is a social construct.
But Gender Identity is fixed in the womb.
The only difference between men and women is their internal knowledge of their gender.
But we need single-gender spaces.
Transgender identities challenge the gender binary by showing that the difference between men and women isn’t clear cut.
But if a trans person is thought to be a man when they’re really a woman, it denies their core identity and makes them suicidal.
Trans culture is all about joy, love and acceptance.
But SUPPORT “TRANS DAY OF VENGEANCE!”
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trans-day-of-vengeance-twitter-marjorie-taylor-greene/
Gender is fixed. Gender is fluid.
People know what gender they are from a very young age. Discovering/learning/deciding one is the “other” gender much later in life.
i. Gender self-knowledge is infallible.
ii. People discover that they are trans/enby.
A person with a beard and a penis is a woman if they say so and if you do not believe this you are a bigot.
A trans person needs surgery to make their body conform with their gender.
It is impossible to determine sex from biology.
Since clownfish can produce sperm in some phase of their life and eggs in another, they prove that sex can change.
Gender is fluid and can change even from day to day.
Even children can know their gender and they will never change their mind about it.
It is a hate crime to refer to people in a way they do not want.
It is o.k. to call a women “cis” because this just describes her.
I’ve noticed an alternative contradiction to this one, as well: people who claim that any sexual developmental disorder at all means that “sex is a spectrum”, and there is a lot of them, and hence trans people are “more common than redheads”. So because there are so many of them, they must be listened to.
No one can know another person’s gender identity, but everyone knows that if Donald Trump says he’s trans to get into the women’s change rooms, he’s lying.
Women are not traumatised or alarmed by male bodies in their change rooms, but trans women are all traumatised and alarmed by male bodies in change rooms, and so must use women’s.