Inching forward
How much “evolution of understanding” does it take?
Gillian Keegan has said she will no longer use the phrase “trans women are women”, explaining that her understanding of the issue has “evolved”.
Why did it need to “evolve”? Does she not know what a woman is? Despite being one herself?
In 2020, in response to a question from an LGBT+ forum in her Chichester constituency, the Education Secretary made the statement that “trans women are women”, adding that trans people should have equal access to “safe spaces”.
Safe spaces in the sense of women’s safe spaces? Trans people including the male ones? Male people should not have access to women’s safe spaces.
But. Good that she’s become better informed, and good that she’s said so.
Her comments were welcomed by Sex Matters, a women’s rights group. Maya Forstater, its chief executive, said: “This change in position by Gillian Keegan is a welcome development and sets an example for other politicians to start using clear, serious language rather than trans activist slogans. For several years, trans activist lobby groups pushed the use of phrases such as ‘trans women are women’ as a tactic to silence debate and fair questions about how gender self-identification clashes with women’s rights. Many didn’t recognise the dangers of these slogans early on, including politicians who doubtless thought they were simply supporting a good cause. It takes guts to publicly change your mind. Women’s rights and the safeguarding of children are serious issues that need to be addressed with clear and accurate language.”
I still wonder at the people who didn’t recognize the dangers of the slogans, especially the female people. It’s not as if they weren’t discussed.
There’s such a mix of confusion, deception, tribalism, and sexism in the trans movement that it’s hard to say in general why people didn’t/don’t recognize the dangers of TWAW/TMAM. Each person will have been moved by a different recipe.
But the people discussing them were the wrong people, or even Unpeople, who happened to be stating the same basics facts as Even Wronger, Right Wing, Fascist Bigot-People. Any greement with these Bad People automatically made anyone so agreeing Bad People as well. This negated the now Fascist facts, making them Officially Unmentionable by Good People, according to (supposedly) Progressive authorities. Any such woman stating these rude, unwelcome, Incorrect facts was now a Karen; any Black woman was rendered Culturally White by expressing such ideas.