Decades of failures
If you’re going to put people in very tall buildings, you need to make sure those buildings are safe.
A damning report on a deadly London high-rise fire concluded Wednesday that decades of failures by government, regulators and industry turned Grenfell Tower into a “death trap” where 72 people lost their lives.
The public inquiry into the 2017 blaze found no “single cause” of the tragedy, but said a combination of dishonest companies, weak or incompetent regulators and complacent government led the building to be covered in combustible cladding that turned a small apartment fire into the deadliest blaze on British soil since World War II.
…
The search for answers focused on a refurbishment completed in 2016 that covered the 1970s building in aluminum and polyethylene cladding — a layer of foam insulation topped by two sheets of aluminum sandwiched around a layer of polyethylene, a combustible plastic polymer that melts and drips on exposure to heat.
The report was highly critical of companies that made the cladding. It said they engaged in “systematic dishonesty,” manipulating safety tests and misrepresenting the results to claim the material was safe.
It said insulation manufacturer Celotex was unscrupulous, and another insulation firm, Kingspan, “cynically exploited the industry’s lack of detailed knowledge.” Cladding panel maker Arconic “concealed from the market the true extent of the danger,” the report said.
…
The inquiry said the combustible cladding was used because it was cheap and because of “incompetence of the organizations and individuals involved in the refurbishment” -– including architects, engineers and contractors — who all thought safety was someone else’s responsibility.
It concluded the failures multiplied because bodies in charge of enforcing building standards were weak, the local authority was uninterested and the “complacent” U.K. government — led in the seven years before the fire by the Conservative Party — ignored safety warnings because of a commitment to deregulation.
Ah yes good old deregulation – let the market decide! So the market decides that profit on combustible cladding now is the way to go.
The Grenfell tragedy prompted soul-searching about inequality in Britain. Grenfell was a public housing building set in one of London’s richest neighborhoods, near the pricey boutiques and elegant houses of Notting Hill.
Well, between one of London’s richest neighborhoods and some more downmarket ones. Notting Hill itself used to be quite scruffy, and Ladbroke Grove is far from elegant. Notting Hill isn’t Kensington or Chelsea, let alone Belgravia or Mayfair.
The victims, largely people of color, came from 23 countries and included taxi drivers and architects, a poet, an acclaimed young artist, retirees and 18 children.
The acclaimed young artist had just won a prize for her work.
The ruined tower, which stood for months after the fire like a black tombstone on the west London skyline, still stands, covered in white sheeting. A green heart and the words “Grenfell forever in our hearts” are emblazoned at the top.
I’m sorry, I’m just an ugly American who doesn’t know how rich these neighborhoods are.
For failings of the type and extent described, someone involved in that building’s creation should have finished up doing a serious stretch inside. Porridge, in other words; to encourage the rest.
I went to the Notting Hill Carnival once, and found it to be alive with pickpockets and petty crooks. Spent a lot of time (successfully) warding them all off.
Others have not been as lucky. See https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c07e55159kro . Not a good look.
Yes, Grenfell. The lack of regulation – even though regulations were there – and the cynical opacity whereby responsibility may be avoided.
I took a look at the building via GoogleEarth and it sure as hell is still there. Imagine living with that looming over you.
Wasn’t one of the reasons for the cladding that the wealthy neighbours thought the original design spoilt their view? (I don’t think it’s visible from Kensington but it certainly is from Holland Park which apparently is London’s Millionaires’ row.)
Colin, #1. As a rough guide, the average house price across London is around £530,000. In Notting Hill, the average is more than three times that, at £1,725,000. Kensington and Chelsea are both around £2,150,000; Belgravia is £3,775,000 and Mayfair £4,200,000.