The silence speaks volumes
Joan Smith on the SNP’s free speech problem:
The silence speaks volumes. Where are the politicians showing solidarity with a colleague who has been no-platformed by a leading Edinburgh venue? Joanna Cherry is an Edinburgh MP, a human rights lawyer and a powerful voice for women’s rights. It’s another example of the demonising of women who hold perfectly legitimate views, allowing them to be picked off and isolated from mainstream politics.
Anyone who claims to believe in basic freedoms should be horrified. So where is Humza Yousaf, leader of the SNP and Cherry’s long-standing colleague? Where is Stephen Flynn, the party leader at Westminster, where Cherry is an MP?
…
[L]eading lawyers have spoken out about the decision to cancel her appearance at The Stand. Roddy Dunlop KC, Dean of the Faculty of Advocates, wrote on Twitter the decision was “plainly unlawful”. Michael Foran, lecturer in law at the University of Glasgow, agreed that it was “unlawful discrimination”.
…
Every time this happens, the objections are based on things the victims of no-platforming have not said. None of the individuals who have been targeted, who include poets and authors as well as politicians, have called for legal rights to be removed from transgender people. They have not demanded that trans people should lose their jobs, be prevented from holding meetings or stopped from carrying out academic research. They are simply upholding the rights of another group, women and especially lesbians, to whom all these things are being done in the name of “trans rights”.
This is what I keep saying. We don’t oppose the human rights of trans people; of course we don’t. We oppose new made-up rights that aren’t rights at all, and that destroy the rights of other people, especially the people formerly known as “women.”
The framing is deliberate because the reality — forcing women to accept biological males in women’s sports, refuges, changing rooms, toilets and prisons — doesn’t sound so appealing. At protests organised by trans activists, we don’t see placards demanding “let men use women’s toilets now” or “make women share cells with rapists”. Instead, we see banners claiming that feminists are calling for “genocide” and comparing a belief in biological sex to Nazi eugenics.
And it goes on and on and on and on…………………
I used to agree women were being suppressed. I used to believe that trans rights were an attack on women’s rights. I used to believe that too many men were using trans as a way to undermine women’s safety and security, but after watching this speech I am now convinced I was wrong.
I have never before heard such a clear and eloquent defence of trans rights.
https://twitter.com/jason_howerton/status/1654123211561529345
Eloquent, succinct and not at all totally fucken’ batshit crazy!
Truly, this SF person is an intellectual titan, the equal of Hannah Arendt and Rebecca West!
And so charismatic, too.
TA: “Why do you care so much, how does it affect you?”
GC: Thanks for asking, here’s where it affects
TA: SHUT THE FUCK UP, BIGOT
I believe the person in that clip is called Lea McGeever. You can see the footage from which that clip was taken here, from 1:09:12 on:
https://sanfrancisco.granicus.com/player/clip/43567?view_id=10&redirect=true&h=b9401c35250cf8308e775ee9ef01adaa
The National Review says it is.
https://www.nationalreview.com/news/i-hate-you-trans-activist-shrieks-at-san-francisco-board-of-supervisors/
Black person gets shot by a (mall) cop in gun crazy America, but hey, it’s all about the trans.