Regardless of their legal status
The Inner Court of Session in Scotland has ruled that guidance issued alongside the census, which informs transgender people they can register as male or female regardless of their legal status, was lawful.
So what does the legal system in Scotland think a census is? Just a kind of diary? A thingy where people get to tell us about their innermost selves? While we pay no attention because we’re too busy talking about our own innermost selves?
It seems pretty silly to throw away money on a “census” that isn’t a census, and it also seems pretty silly to have an inaccurate “census” – that isn’t a census because it permits counterfactual answers.
This means that the census in Scotland in 2022 will not collect clear and reliable data on sex.
In the words of the Scottish Government’s counsel “the census is a ten yearly collection of data from the population used to inform strategic policy and allocation of resources and understanding of the country’s population”. The ability of public authorities and researchers to use the data from this year’s census for this purpose has now been damaged.
It’s a collection of data – not a collection of fee-fees. You can’t inform policy and allocate resources and understand the country’s population if you tell people “Go ahead and lie about yourself on the census.”
Scotland seems bound and determined to go down this route no matter what.
Scotland.
I have had a love affair with Scotland since I was a kid, but they have made some spectacularly awful choices through history.
When it came to religious reform, they picked John Knox and Presbyterianism. Battlefield Band has a song about a yew tree, a tree supposed to see through history and the future. A verse asks the yew tree:
Did ye no’ think to tell
When John Knox himsel’
Preached under your branches sae black
Tae the poor common folk
Who would lift up the yoke
O’ the bishops and priests frae their backs?
But you knew the bargain he sold them,
And freedom was only one part,
For the price o’ their souls
Was a gospel sae cold
It would freeze up the joy in their hearts.
Then again, they backed the Jacobite pretenders to the throne, with disastrous results.
There almost seems to be a streak of stubborn self-destruction in the Scottish character. Very dismaying to a confirmed Caledoniaphile like me.