Enjoy your childish tantrum
Just as you can’t “cut ties” with the Supreme Court.
It’s very Trumpy to say you’re cutting ties with a supervisory board you can’t cut ties with.
Libby Brooks at the Guardian has more:
The UK’s equalities watchdog has written to the Scottish government asking it to pause plans to simplify the legal requirements for gender recognition.
LGBT+ equality campaigners hit back at the unexpected intervention by the Equality and Human Rights Commission, describing its approach as “deeply troubling” and “failing to stand up for equality for trans people”.
That is they reacted; they didn’t hit anyone. I do wish UK journalists would drop this “hit out/hit back” rhetoric, it sounds so childish.
The EHRC, which monitors equality and human rights across England, Scotland and Wales, told Shona Robison, the minister responsible for the reforms, that “more detailed consideration” was required.
…
The letter, sent from ECHR chair, Baroness Kishwer Falkner, to Robison on Wednesday afternoon, raised concern “at the polarised debate” around transgender law reform.
Kishwer Falkner wrote that “some lawyers, academics, data users and others have increasingly expressed concerns about the potential implications of changing the current criteria for obtaining a Gender Recognition Certificate”.
“The potential consequences include those relating to the collection and use of data, participation and drug testing in competitive sport, measures to address barriers facing women, and practices within the criminal justice system, inter alia”.
You know, little things, like measures to address barriers facing women.
In my opinion, a factor in a tantrum like this is people who went from undergrad to grad school to a nonprofit org, and they don’t understand the context of their org in society — e.g. the accountability the of the LGBT Foundation to the EHRC.
I also see this pattern of people lacking context and accountability in the journal Hypatia melting down over the Tuvel paper on transracialism (2017). For Hypatia to exist, Hypatia is owned by a corporation, and published by John Wiley & Sons, a $1.7 billion a year business traded on the NYSE. Wiley is accountable to stockholders and the SEC, so Wiley has a statement of their business ethics. The stunt against Tuvel met my reading of the Wiley definition of business fraud (but to be clear, that is not criminal fraud). I have to imagine that Wiley needed to write a “get well” plan about the mess. Hypatia was lucky that Wiley did not simply drop Hypatia to clean house.
Dennis is always brilliant value.