Born in the wrong body
From the afternoon session. I don’t see a thread reader yet so I’ll just quote from tweets directly.
Discussions around ‘born in the wrong body’ narrative. BB explains terms have evolved but some T ppl still use it. KM – Ed Dept published guidance not to use. You made a statement following this you wouldn’t promote that narrative.
BB: I have no recollection of this guidance being the reason though. Was emerging discussion. If so we managed to respond v quickly.
KM: would you have been involved in consultation on DoE guidance?
BB: dont know
KM: met with civil servants / ministers involved?
BB: would like to, don’t know in this case
KM reading through the guidance. If LGBA were to have criticised the narrative born in wrong body that would not have been problematic?
BB: complicated. DoE is guidance not fact on lived reality of trans people’s lives. It seems ok as guidance to me but some trans people use the term.
The “lived reality of trans people’s lives” she refers to is the “born in the wrong body” fairy tale. “Lived reality” in this sort of context translates to “lived fantasy.”
Fantasy can be very important in people’s lives, and can also be healthy and enriching and so on. But it needs to be recognized as fantasy, not translated into “lived reality.”
KM moving on to LGBA schools material. LGBA dont think children should be confused or upset by ideology, agree?
BB: not the way we would speak about this issue to kids
KM: But reflects what Cass found that we need to be careful
BB: I think Cass didn’t use the word ideology
Ah yes, you don’t like that word, do you. But it is an ideology. It’s not just a Big Box of Facts.
KM: used belief. moving on – if child isn’t gender conforming shouldn’t lead educator to say trans
BB: agree not appropriate
KM: A GNC child eg girl who plays football might well be led to think trans …
BB: No this is section 28, being trans is not easy, implausible.
Is it though? With all the frantic valorization and sympathy going on? Is it really implausible that young teenagers would start calling themselves trans in this climate?
KM: Template letter here about RSE guidance and ‘what we cannot accept that children should be taught can be Born In The Wrong Body’.
BB: I can’t believe that was being taught.
Why not?
There is no way to verify that a child is “born in the wrong body.” There is no description of how a mind can be different from the body’s sex in a gender ID except for, yes, dualism. That thing that naturalists reject as contra-causal.
Being born in the wrong body is being born in the state of original sin. And the only way to fix that is to mutilate the body, no much more moral than self-flagellation.
Gay kids being told they must be born again.