Whose words
Nolan Investigates Stonewall is now available In Your Area so I’m listening. It starts with how can the BBC possibly claim to be impartial when it’s part of the Stonewall Says We’re Awesome scheme? Will it move down the league table because of this podcast?
And then a very important question: is the language they use when reporting on trans issues BBC language or Stonewall language?
Aha, thought I. Stonewall language. That’s why we keep seeing these stupid platitudes with their stupid wording. Of course it is. That’s why people keep babbling about “trans rights” without ever explaining what rights trans people have that the rest of us don’t. That’s why there’s all this Most Oppressed Most Marginalized Most Excluded hyperbole even though it is such bullshit. It’s all Stonewall Language.
I just saw someone I used to respect, tweeting about the guy whose daughter was (allegedly) raped at her school, calling him “anti-trans.” How is he anti-trans??? Because he wants his daughter’s school not to pretend her rape didn’t happen? Because he said the boy was wearing a skirt? Is he supposed to just accept his daughter’s rape? Does that hold even if the boy isn’t trans at all but just exploiting the new toilet rules?
Stonewall Language. A pox on it.
Having just read Rob’s comments in the Guest Post, your last paragraph is doubly enraging How can we possibley thinlk first of the needs of the rapist. It’s a continuation of the cases such as in Youngstown, OH, where a gang rape by football players was seen as a terrible thing to do to the boys’ future. Why, they had promising college careers waring for them at WVU, Pitt, THE Ohio State, playing football for scholarships, and then this hussy got drunk and tried to ruin them. How can this dad want to hurt the transwoman who has trauma?