His official duties
During the presidential campaign, Joseph R. Biden Jr., then the Democratic candidate, slammed his opponent, Donald J. Trump, for a highly unusual legal move: bringing in the Justice Department to represent him in a defamation lawsuit stemming from a decades-old rape allegation.
At one of their debates, Mr. Biden accused Mr. Trump of treating the Justice Department like his “own law firm” in the suit, filed against him by the writer E. Jean Carroll. “What’s that all about?” he sarcastically asked.
But now…his DoJ is defending Trump against Carroll.
But on Monday night, nearly eight months after Mr. Biden’s attack, his own Justice Department essentially adopted Mr. Trump’s position, arguing that he could not be sued for defamation because he had made the supposedly offending statements as part of his official duties as president.
In a brief filed with a federal appeals court in New York, the Justice Department acknowledged that Mr. Trump’s remarks about Ms. Carroll were “crude and disrespectful,” but the department also claimed that the Trump administration’s arguments were correct — a position that could lead to Ms. Carroll’s lawsuit being dismissed.
How can it be part of the official duties of a president to make defamatory remarks about a woman he sexually assaulted? I’m not seeing the duties part, or the official part. He was having a tantrum, and fending off a personal threat – that’s not his “official duties.” That’s personal.
I’m not the only one who thinks so, either.
last September, one month after a state judge issued a ruling that potentially opened the door to Mr. Trump sitting for a deposition before the election, the attorney general, William P. Barr, stepped into the case. In a highly unusual move, Mr. Barr transferred the case to federal court and substituted the federal government for Mr. Trump as the defendant.
Federal law forbids government employees from being sued for defamation, meaning that if the move was successful, Ms. Carroll’s claim would be dismissed.
Mr. Barr’s move raised the question of whether Mr. Trump had in fact made his comments about Ms. Carroll as a government employee — a position that Ms. Carroll’s lawyers roundly rejected. “There is not a single person in the United States — not the president and not anyone else — whose job description includes slandering women they sexually assaulted,” the lawyers said in a filing last year.
What I’m saying. Not official duties. Personal time; off the clock; extracurricular.
The brief filed on Monday night was the first time the Biden administration’s Justice Department, now led by Attorney General Merrick B. Garland, weighed in on the issue. In the brief, department lawyers said that when Mr. Trump had denied raping Ms. Carroll, through the White House press office or in statements to reporters in the Oval Office and on the White House lawn, he was acting within the scope of his office.
No, it’s the other way around. The filthy sleazebag used that “office” to defend his own personal worthless hide. Defaming the woman he assaulted doesn’t become an official duty just because he does it inside the building.
Of course we’re talking about someone whose entire “presidency” was entirely “Personal time; off the clock; extracurricular.”
Morally speaking, yes, but unfortunately he did have the power to do many many many official things, however personally and amateurishly and self-indulgently he did them. Giving medals to people like Rush Limbaugh, that was official.
Well, we know that “when the president does it, that means that it is not illegal”, as St. Richard said, but does it turn it into an official part of the job?
GW:
I take it you are referring to ‘St Richard Nixon’; on one view (as he was a Quaker) now up there residing with the angels and singing hymns of praise 24/7.
Nixon had trouble with distinctions and differences, such as the difference between national security and Nixon security. Could be something in the White House water supply. Trump had much the same problem, and regarded the DoJ as his own personal law firm and cheer squad, and himself as POTUS as being outranked only by God; in whom he trusted. To be more precise, he trusted God is to turn a blind eye to a lot of his shagging activities. That in turn must have created problems for God, who has to be omniscient at all times in order to keep His job.
One damned thing leads to another.