Cooking the prisoners
Apparently labor laws and safety laws don’t apply to prisoners.
Temperatures reached 97 degrees on June 21 at the French Robinson Unit prison the day Seth Donnelly collapsed. The Texas Observer reported Seth passed out during his prison job of training attack dogs — running around in a 75-pound “fight suit” while the dogs tried to bite him. Seth’s internal body temperature was 106 when he reached the hospital, where doctors eventually took him off life support. He died on June 23, and his preliminary autopsy lists multiorgan failure following severe hyperthermia.
97 degrees. A padded suit weighing 75 pounds. It’s worthy of the tunnels at Camp Dora.
Danielle, who asked for In These Times to withhold her last name to protect her family-run business from social stigma, says she woke up in her cell in Texas at Gatesville Prison one typical early morning in July 2015, drenched in sweat. Without time (or permission) to shower or brush her teeth, she reports she was corralled to the fields in a heavy uniform.
“It didn’t feel safe,” says Danielle, who explains she picked tomatoes and jalapeño peppers without pay. Gatesville’s average high temperature that month was 98 degrees. “Texas in July, it’s like sitting on hell’s doorstep,” she says.
A guard who Danielle says she was “deathly terrified of” patrolled the “state property” (the term guards used for incarcerated people) on a horse. Danielle says she was not provided gloves, which often left her hands exposed to thorns and caustic jalapeño juices.
OSHA [Occupational Safety and Health Administration] rules do not apply to state prisons. Twenty-two states have adopted OSHA “state plans,” which cover state prisons with standards intended to be at least as effective as federal standards. Eight of the 10 states with the highest incarceration rates have declined to adopt these plans.
“The guards could literally do whatever they wanted to us,” says Danielle, who was incarcerated in Texas from August 2014 to September 2015..
Danielle’s stated working conditions appear antithetical to OSHA’s guidelines. “There was a vehicle that would come by and bring some water, but if the vehicle broke down you were out of luck for water that day,” she says. “That happened numerous times. Even when we get water it was gone within a few minutes and they won’t refill it for you. There are 50-plus women and the women in the back don’t get any.”
That causes death. It also causes misery of course, but it kills. Extreme heat is lethal, and hydration is essential.
Nearly half of people imprisoned in the U.S. work while incarcerated, a population disproportionately likely to be Black. Penal labor became a more significant part of the American economy following the Civil War; police would conduct sweeps and make arrests of Black men when plantations needed additional labor for planting, cutting and harvesting crops. Today, a majority of incarcerated workers perform “institutional maintenance,” which includes tasks like mowing the compound lawn and mopping floors. A relatively small number of others work in “correctional industries,” manufacturing things like license plates, sewing American flags and — as in Danielle’s case — harvesting vegetables that are later sold for a profit. All seven states that don’t pay for non-industry labor are in the South, which can reach dangerously hot summer temperatures.
And which are former slave states, and then Jim Crow states. Not a coincidence.
This makes me wonder: Is this where our tomatoes and jalapeño peppers are coming from?! Are we supporting lethal prison work when we buy vegetables?
Camp Dora? I doubt the overseers were rocket scientists.
@GW:
Depends where you live… They’re probably certified “locally grown and organic” or some such. More likely to come from Mexico or California I’d think.
Having done my doctoral research in Texas, I can vouch for that. I was in the Texas fields in the hottest months of summer, but I had water, a shaded 4×4, a proper hat, gloves, and the ability to leave if I started to dehydrate. This seems like the bare minimum (okay, not necessarily the 4×4; it was a blast, and got me into places I couldn’t have gotten to otherwise, but I did my master’s research without one, so that one is probably not the bare minimum, but a nice perk).
The problem is, most people will shrug and say “they’re criminals” if you tell them about conditions in the prisons. “Don’t do the crime if you can’t do the time” is a favorite. In Texas, they’re not even that nice. Never mind that many of them are incarcerated for things the people saying that might have done, like smoke a joint. A lot of Texans don’t differentiate between a drug user and a mass murderer; they’re just criminals.
So slavery, then, conveniently allowed by Fourteenth Amendment, even if it abrogates international law and offends basic human decency.
In Germany, prisoners are also forced (or ‘duty bound’, if you’re feeling generous) to work; the difference is, here, prisoner workers earn a living wage for their labour which they are paid upon their release as a way of helping them get back on their feet. I’m not sure, but I also imagine the working conditions are quite tightly regulated. I’m also sure there are abuses and injustices, but I cannot imagine people here being worked to death for no money.
Ahh, after double-checking, it appears “living wage” may be overstating things a bit. See here: https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2016/aug/2/german-prisoners-form-union-seek-minimum-wage-and-pension/
So Germany is not some kind of prisoner worker’s paradise. Still a damned sight better than the slavery of the US, though.
“Tough on crime” = killing prisoners.
Casual cruelty, I despise. This is different. People have become invested in cruelty. Cruelty has become the purpose and the reason.
When I lived in Texas, Ann Richards was the governor. Clayton Williams, a rich guy, ran against her and his ad campaign was set in the desert sun, with prisoners in black and white stripe suits. The tagline for his campaign to end drug use was “I’ll introduce them to the joys of bustin’ rocks.” He lost the election in part because of a comment about how the weather is like rape, and also because people could see he was a yokel (which counted for something up until they elected George W. after I had moved away.)
It’s a popular theme, not just in Texas, but also in Arizona where Sheriff Joe erected a tent city in the heat of Phoenix. “Criminals are not really people, they’re criminals.”
Colin Day @ 2 – Yes, Camp Dora. I KNOW the guards are not rocket scientists – the point is that the conditions for the slaves in those tunnels were horrific and lethal, and the slaves died of hyperthermia. I think the meaning of “97 degrees. A padded suit weighing 75 pounds. It’s worthy of the tunnels at Camp Dora.” is perfectly obvious. What is the point of a snotty comment like that?
Some additional perspective on penal attitudes in the United States of America, the Land of the Free:
https://www.lawyersgunsmoneyblog.com/2021/07/life-in-prison
There’s no real benefit to society for life in prison except for dedicated recidivists (like pedophiles and domestic abusers,) so why even refer to them as reformatories if we keep people locked up from 18 to death?
As Papillon dreamed “We find you guilty of a wasted life.”
Why is there such a wide, deep vein of cruelty in American culture? Why do we celebrate mean-ness? I can understand the feeling of some voters that the elites don’t listen to us, but why choose the meanest, most venal, a%%$hole as the solution? Unless Trump simply appealed to that vein of mean-ness.
It’s not as if there’s more to him than that…