Time with Tik Tok
That article by Tina Traster dropped by Psychology Today and picked up by Transgender Trend:
Tina Traster is a socially-conscious, award-winning journalist, author, and filmmaker. She is the director of the award-winning documentary Catnip Nation and author of the award-winning memoir Rescuing Julia Twice: A Mother’s Tale of Russian Adoption and Overcoming Reactive Attachment Disorder. She has written about the transgender trend for Psychology Today. We are happy to re-publish her post here.
Traster notes that a lot of LGBQT teenagers are in foster care.
Let’s talk about trans kids. The generally accepted narrative among activists, the therapeutic community, and the media is that many trans kids are living with parents who reject them based on morality or intolerance. However, there are legions of parents who themselves are being rejected because they have not picked up a pair of pom poms to cheer their tween or teen through cross-dressing, name-changing, hormone-treatment and life-altering surgeries.
Parents who detected signs of gender dysphoria in their very young or prepubescent children might feel more comfortable in accepting that their child really has been disordered for a long time. But a different cohort – those grappling with a sudden “coming out” as trans at 13, 14 or even through their 20s, remain skeptical. That skepticism guided a study done by researcher Dr. Lisa Littman, who looked at why a sudden spate of teen girls were announcing themselves as trans.
Remember being a teenager? The way I remember it it involved a lot of reacting to the examples of one’s peers – sometimes against, sometimes for.
Littman’s ground-breaking but controversial research focused on feedback from parents who largely said their daughter’s decision to become “trans” came out of nowhere or appeared to be related to social contagion within a friend group. Littman coined the term “Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria,” which is threatening to those who believe any self-diagnosed trans-declared person deserves to be affirmed as such and should have access to any medical care to achieve transition.
And, more profoundly, that being trans is existential, is an absolute and incontrovertible truth, is as basic and true as being human, being alive, being conscious. (There are philosophical disputes over how true it is that we are conscious, but they don’t influence teenagers much.)
In today’s culture, children spend more time with Tik Tok, Reddit, and Instagram than they do with their parents. Children believe every question can be answered on Google. If they’re looking for role models, social media influencers are there to cheerfully guide any journey, particularly for children who are led to believe they may be trans. It’s a strong suction, the internet. One that parents can hardly compete with. Add to that the new normal – a world where the policies of schools, summer camps, therapists, doctors, and social communities – reinforce the notion that being trans is cool and normal and should be supported no matter what.
There’s a bit of a tension there, an interesting one. Being cool isn’t the same as being normal, and sometimes carefully deviates from it. Being cool is often a matter of rejecting the normal in favor of something more interesting or attention-getting. It’s true though that trans activism promotes both. This could help to explain some of the…peculiarity of the rhetoric.
Amid this pull, parents are experiencing parenting dysphoria, as they fight to preserve their relationships with children who are often taught to treat them as if they are the toxic ones. Parents tell their trans declared children that they are worried about them, that they don’t think they should make life-altering decisions, that they’re young and they should explore slowly. In return, trans children will recite what they’ve learned to parrot from internet influencers and activists. They will call these parents transphobes. They treat parents like the enemy. They will demand total buy-in or the gig is over.
And Jolyon Maugham QC, full-fledged adult, will come galloping over the horizon on his purple trans-horse to tell them they’re totally right and the oldies are wrong except for him, Jolyon Maugham QC.
There are philosophical disputes over how true it is that we are conscious,
How do nonconscious beings engage in disputes?
There was an item on the news this morning about the new Mayor of Tilloy-lez-Marchiennes:
You may not have heard of Tilloy-lez-Marchiennes, but it has all of 550 inhabitants. (Cabriès, 20 times bigger, is not far from where I am, but you could be forgiven for not having heard of it either.) Anyway, I wasn’t paying attention to the introduction explaining why this was major world news, and only started doing so when we were introduced to the Mayor, a very tall person who looked down to the interviewer, an honest-to-god woman of normal size. On first seeing the Mayor I had difficulty deciding whether I was seeing a man or a woman, or perhaps a man pretending to be a woman.
Colin #1, see http://psych.fullerton.edu/mbirnbaum/psych101/Eliza.htm
Heh.
How do I dispute Eliza if I’m not conscious? I suppose one could have two Elizas “talking” to each other, but is it really a dispute?
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/consciousness/
“How do nonconscious beings engage in disputes?”
They file suits to overturn elections in court.
I think it is a fad. In 62 years i have met 2 or 3 real ones. “He” was named Tomarro, aka Frank Zahne. From near Tuba City, AZ. At the time they were channeling Joni Mitchell. They were an interesting person and fun to be with. But because they were living double, it was important to be careful. I don’t think Tomarro fits into the current trans thing. They were more like something i don’t understand, some kind of injun doctor. Hard to explain.
I forgot to tell you about Winona. She and her husband stopped by our shop. In those days, we were so poor, we picked up pretty rocks to sell for the visitors.
I was so confused! But they were nice. They bought a couple pretty rocks. They were from cedar city so we used a few local words. That is the first time i met a trans person.
It was strange for me because i had not seen this before. I had a million questions!
I still think about them sometimes. It was a good encounter.