“But What Was She Wearing? “
Vaishnavi Sundar finds out what it’s like to be canceled:
I am a filmmaker, writer and a women’s rights activist. I spend my time advocating for equal opportunities, contraceptive rights, education and the empowerment of women and girls. I centre women in all my work. When I started screening my film on workplace sexual harassment across India, I was hoping to raise public consciousness. But What Was She Wearing? was India’s first feature-length documentary on the subject.
However, I encountered strong resistance to the film from liberal feminist gatekeepers. Women who would send me private messages asking for professional favours and contacts, and congratulate me on the film, refused to acknowledge my presence on their public timelines or retweet anything about the film. At first, I thought this was my eternal bad luck or some flaw in my personality.
Then the rejections started, from lefty publications that had snapped up everything she sent in the past.
Last month, I discovered the reason I had become a social outcast in liberal-feminist bastions. I was in the US for an exchange programme, and I wanted to use the opportunity to screen my film at various places while I toured the country. One screening was scheduled in New York, organised by the Polis Project. The proverbial i’s were dotted, posters designed and I was even introduced to a female Indian moderator. But a week before the screening, the organiser (also a woman of Indian origin) sent me an email. She said the event would be cancelled because of my ‘transphobic’ views.
So feminist work on subjects like sexual harassment is worth nothing compared to the outrage of “transphobic” views. In other words the hell with what women are concerned about, are they being accommodating enough to men???? This from left-wing outlets.
Many moons ago I got into a Twitterspat about pre-op trans women in women’s shelters, prisons, bathrooms and women’s sports. And someone had brought the tweets in question to the organisers’ attention. As a result, the Polis Project thought it was only fair to shelve a screening of a film about a pressing topic that affects women across all social strata in society. All because the filmmaker believes biological sex is not a social construct, that women’s sex-based oppression is real, that housing people with male genitalia in spaces with victims of male sexual violence can be harrowing to women inmates, that mental illnesses like autogynephilia and other dysphorias can cause dangerous, irrevocable damage, and that gender theorists are erasing women, much like patriarchy does.
Feminism just doesn’t matter now because men who long to wear fuck-me shoes matter so much more.
I have since confronted the editors of the publications that blacklisted me. It appears that Indian trans-rights activists googled my name and wrote to every outlet I had ever been published in, telling them about my ‘TERFy’ tweets.
That’s the way to win hearts and minds.
How can so many liberal feminists call themselves ‘liberal’ and laud pornography, an industry in which women are brutalised (and often killed)? How can you encourage children to be ‘drag queens’ performing sexual acts for adults, in the name of gender ideology? I wish they wouldn’t call it a movement anymore. It is a cult that extols men, who are often not really ‘queer’ but who want to take advantage of ‘self-identifying’ as a woman in order to gain oppression points and external validation.
Feminism 2020: all about the men now.
The fix is in.
Trans Holdings is the company to watch. They will consolidate their share portfolio, and then unload the lot when the price is right.
Omar, I’m just waiting to see what will boot out trans for the most oppressed ever, most suicidal, most murdered ever, and start telling trans to sit down and shut up, you nasty bigoted oppressor, you. Then watch them squawk.
iknklast,
That will really chuck some petrol on their fire. And who knows? It might have just about gone out of its own accord by then anyway. So careful there, careful.
One of the early radio shock-jocks of Sydney, where I grew up, had a motto: “speak well of my name, speak ill of my name; but speak my name..!” He even did not mind people laughing AT him. Few laughed with him, as he was pretty humourless, and took himself very seriously indeed.
(His name was Eric Baume.)
iknklast:
Don’t worry, whatever the new super-oppressed group turns out to be it’s sure to be full to the brim of white men. I don’t imagine the transition will be too difficult.
Continual shittiness. “Eve-teasing” as it’s horribly called, i.e. sexual harassment, is rife in India. And a woman makes a film about it and can’t show the film.
If only Eve had the good sense to start life as Evan, then discover her innate gender identity, then films could be shown about her plight. It’s her own fault for daring to be born cis- and having all that cis-privilege, so much so that she is oppressing middle-class white men who think they are women.