Imagine for a moment
This is not a good argument.
Imagine for a moment how this allegation would read (and what the reaction would be) if the word "trans" was replaced with the name of any other minority group within our society: https://t.co/F2Dicb7zKC
— Stop Funding Hate (@StopFundingHate) July 28, 2019
It’s not a good argument because, first, any minority group? But that could be rapists, or psychopaths, or serial killers, or greedy landlords who don’t make repairs (hello Jared Kushner!), or members of the KKK. Being part of a minority group doesn’t automatically make people right about everything. And second because the trans lobby is in fact a special case, so swapping in for instance “feminist lobby pressure” wouldn’t do the work Stop Funding Hate wants it to do. The trans lobby does in fact apply fierce pressure to everyone it can reach to accept and echo and flatter the dogma about what it is to be trans.
I’ll quote again a bit from that Guardian piece that I quoted from yesterday:
Evans said that since his resignation he had become concerned that the debate around transitioning had been shut down by a vocal minority. “The mind that is free to think or ask difficult questions is treated as a real threat; TV producers and journalists continually report that while people are willing to speak in confidence to them about their reservations about treatment in these areas, they shy away from being named, for fear of being accused of being bigoted and transphobic and sometimes either disciplined or even sacked for speaking their mind.”
Emphasis added. We know that’s not a foolish or empty fear; we know it happens. We just saw it happen to another blog at Freethought Blogs earlier in the week. We saw it happen to the Vancouver Public Library, told it can’t be part of Pride because it allowed Meghan Murphy to give a talk in its building. We know it happens. The allegation is not a false one.
Hear, hear.
Minority group is such an interesting concept, considering that one of the oppressed groups (women) is actually in the majority, while the dominant group (white men) is a smaller group. It is possible for a minority to oppress a majority. That was the whole (false) construct behind the idea of the Moral Majority and Nixon’s Silent Majority – that these groups were being oppressed by a minority of citizens. Just because it wasn’t true for them doesn’t mean it isn’t true for women.
And Christian evangelicals are certainly a minority group, but imagine this with that in place:
Both true, and horrifying.