But there is a study!
Rod Liddle congratulates the men winning women’s competitions:
Already a Democratic party representative, Ilhan Omar of Minnesota, is insisting that the US powerlifting tournaments allow transgender women to compete, so that people who look very much like Geoff Capes, and have the same chromosomes as Geoff Capes, and the same bone structure and musculature, can compete against women. Meanwhile, the fastest female college sprinter in the US is CeCe Telfer, who, once again, is not what you or I or science would call a lady, and one of the world champions in women’s cycling is a chap called Rachel McKinnon, whom I have mentioned here before.
…
Those who support the rights of transgender women to compete in women’s sports often cite the only piece of research done on the issue which ‘proves’ that it is a myth that transgender women have an advantage over normal women. This study was published in 2015 and is cited every time the issue arises — but I have one or two problems with it, to tell you the truth. First, it concerned a total of just eight athletes, which is a smallish sample (no control group, either). Second, it was not carried out by a qualified geneticist or social scientist, but by a ‘medical physicist’ by the name of Joanna Harper. And third, Joanna Harper, once an athlete herself, was, um, how can I put this, not always called Joanna. She was raised as a boy and transitioned to being a fairly fast lady in her thirties. So she has skin in the game and we might surmise that she, or he, set out to prove a thesis, rather than, in good Popperian practice, trying to disprove it.
Other than that…
https://medium.com/@Antonia_Lee/the-iocs-transgender-guidelines-are-unscientific-and-pose-a-serious-risk-to-the-health-of-both-5f5f808748e2
Another excellent relevant article from Antonia Lee (a pseudonym, I think?) in Medium:
https://medium.com/@Antonia_Lee/transgender-sporting-participation-time-to-frame-the-debate-b78bac4308b2
There was some tale that one of those alleged 8 trans athletes from that study has never been identified or proven to exist………….just saying. And, yes, no control sample. And self-reported times so if, say somebody wanted to coast a bit and show a lower time set for the study then go full out on race days to cheat wins from real women….not that hard to do.
Please don’t make me agree with anything Rod Liddle says ever again.