An alternative narrative
So we might as well read that open letter to Jen Gunter by Jennifer Lang.
There is nothing the patriarchy likes to see more than a good cat-fight. I read your open letter to Ms Paltrow when it was published in 2017, and at the time found it very unfortunate. I, too, struggled with whether it was worth my time or mental energy making a public response as urgent social, environmental and political events piled up around us. I decided to classify your letter as yet one more public beat-down of a female voice offering an alternative narrative to the monopoly-on-truth claimed by the western medical model. I ignored it. However, the publication of your new book and in particular the Guardian Interview article I read this morning have goaded me into a response.
First, I’ll say that I have no interest in participating in a take-down of any woman, least of all a single mom with medically-challenged kids who (I truly believe) is trying to help. This f***ed up patriarchal world does enough of that every single day. I celebrate strong female voices, professional success, and especially doctors who have found ways to bring in alternative revenue streams as insurance company reimbursements decline by double-digits annually. That being said, the condescending tone and overall arrogance of the stance you take on these issues is, in my opinion, the precise reason why so many women are moving away from allopathic medicine and seeking alternative or complementary care and sources of information.
I find in your words a callous blanket dismissal of the lived and felt experience of women, justified by the claim that you are an “expert.” What I do not encounter in anything you have written or been quoted as saying in an interview, is a genuine humility regarding our understanding of the complexities of the human body, nor an acknowledgment that the dominant medical advice of the moment has often been subsequently proven erroneous. I do not hear or see any responsibility-taking for the well-documented and very serious harms that have resulted from women unquestioningly following the advice of experts like ourselves prescribing pharmaceuticals and surgical interventions.
In other words Gunter doesn’t frame her criticism of the exploitative, expensive bullshit of Goop within apologies for the mistakes doctors have made in the past. But why should she? Why can’t she focus on Paltrow’s profitable scam which wouldn’t be so profitable if it weren’t marketed as “alternative” and “spiritual” and womany? Personally, I find Lang’s invocation of “lived and felt experience of women” far more annoying than anything Gunter says. Why can’t Lang do her thing and let Gunter do hers?
Well, she’s not wrong. Woo will never prove that red crystals don’t rebalance your upper-left chakra.
How much humility are we seeing from people peddling devices, concoctions or therapies not proven to work, or proven to actually harm? I think science has a lot of humility about the limits of its knowledge. Science is always asking the next question, trying to break what it thinks works because it might be wrong. At its best, it is self corrective, assessing old ideas in light of new information. How much cutting edge research have alternative therapies offered? In what ways are these “alternate modalities” keeping themselves updated? Do they learn from their mistakes? How much more than just the placebo effect and a pleasant bedside manner do they have to offer, and have they actually looked at just how much themselves? Using a different branch of ancient, alternative modalities, how many astrologers have taken into account the existence of scores and scores of moons discovered around planets of the outer solar system, some of which rival and excede the size of the planet Mercury? This sort of new data should help make them better at doing their job. How many have been looking into how these bodies should be incorporated into their charts? I’m guessing that number is close to zero. Have alternative practitioners been engaging in anything equivalent, given how much humans have learned about the body in the last two centuries or so?
The alternative crowd has no humility about the depths of its ignorance and self-delusion. I imagine that Dr. Gunter can come up with quite a long list of “well-documented and very serious harms that have resulted from women unquestioningly following the advice” of quacks and charlatans. A virus, bacteria or broken bone doesn’t give a shit about what you “believe” or your “lived experience.” The prayers of millions and a good sugical team is worth the surgical team. When I’m sick or injured, I’ll take a grouchy, “arrogant”, Western-trained doctor using evidence-based medecine over the kindest, gentlest, most well-meaning and sympathetic person in the world with red crystals offering to align my upper left chakra.
not Bruce, not only do they not update or try to change their methods, they actually promote the idea that these ideas have been around a long time (even if they have to make that up for some new idea that they stick “ancient Chinese medicine” onto).
Science is the medium that has discovered the mistakes of medicine and science; woo claims their cures are superior because they are old. Oh, and they are “eastern” (even when they are not), therefore, woke. And feminine. Because the western is masculine, I suppose? They just lump words like “western”, “masculine”, “patriarchal”, “misogynistic”, and anything else they can think of, and throw it into a blender to make some sort of woke milkshake. That is usually their sole argument – I’m woke, and you’re not.
If using evidence-based medicine makes me asleep, I’ll stay asleep. I could take all the herbs in the world, and it wouldn’t likely help my asthma as much as the medicines (chemicals!) I take…which have improved by leaps and bounds over my lifetime, so the side effects no longer leave me shaking and unable to pipet a solution.
And for those who scream about chemicals, what the hell do they think herbs are? Or water, for that matter?
How could you leave off the epic first line of the open letter?
Thanks, Skeletor, I just had to go read that once you mentioned it. Now I will struggle to sleep without dreaming of that weirdness.
Sorry, iknklast.
If it’s any consolation — and I’m sure it’s not — it sounds like you’re not the only one that has problem sleeping.