Promoting the white supremacists
NPR is doing its bonehead “both sides” thing again.
In a “Morning Edition” segment, the radio host Noel King interviewed Jason Kessler, a white nationalist who is planning a rally in Washington this weekend on the anniversary of last year’s rally, which was the scene of racist chants and deadly violence.
Ms. King preceded the discussion, which was part of a weeklong series about the anniversary of the Charlottesville rally, with a warning: “Some of what you’re about to hear is racist and offensive.”
Why talk to a white nationalist at all? Why give a white nationalist a huge respectable platform? Why promote white nationalism on NPR?
In the interview on Friday, which lasted about five minutes, Mr. Kessler relayed junk science and ranked the intelligence of various races.
Ms. King at times pushed back and interrupted Mr. Kessler. Before he made his remarks on race-ranking, which he has supported by citing a political scientist, she said the scholar’s work had been “debunked by scientists and sociologists, and is deemed racist by many.”
“and is deemed racist by many”; typical NPR “some people think X while other people think Y.” Yes we know that, but sometimes what people think is just wrong.
She asked Mr. Kessler: “You said that you’re not a white supremacist, but you do think there are differences between races. What are the differences?”
After he answered with his intelligence rankings, claiming black people were the least smart, she said: “You don’t sound like someone who wants to unite people when you say something like that. You sound like someone who wants to tick people off.”
What you say is deemed racist by many; you don’t sound like someone who wants to unite people; you sound like someone who wants to tick people off – it’s all reception with them, all appearances, all reaction, all some think boo and some think bah. It’s as if NPR puts their brains in a blender and then redistributes them evenly among the entire staff.
NPR stood by the report on Friday. Terence Samuel, the deputy managing editor of NPR News, said in an interview that he was “proud of the job Noel did this morning.”
Oh ffs – there again, it’s not about how the on-air personality performed, it’s about the substance, and giving the substance a huge megaphone.
“I think it’s important for us to cover race and racism, and quite frankly, if you’re going to do that, you have to talk to racists,” he said. “It’s uncomfortable, but we do that all the time.”
Not on the air you don’t.
https://twitter.com/adamdavidson/status/1028241667021778944
https://twitter.com/adamdavidson/status/1028279987097534464
https://twitter.com/adamdavidson/status/1028281192590860293
Q. Do you know what you're doing?
NPR: We're not taking sides here.
Q. Okay, but have you talked to people who study white supremacists about interviewing them?
NPR: We're not endorsing one view over another.
Q. Let me ask this another way…
NPR: We're not promoting anything.— Jay Rosen (@jayrosen_nyu) August 10, 2018
Good rule would be: Don't interview a white supremacist until you have read the Oxygen of Amplification. https://t.co/90J6RkLB0Y https://t.co/BWPGwoMgH8
— Jay Rosen (@jayrosen_nyu) August 11, 2018
Treating issues of truth and falsehood as ‘opinion’ is not responsible reporting, and never has been. ‘Many people think,’ and ‘some people say’ is the kind of evidence that Trump spouts.
It isn’t ‘freezepeach’ to treat crackpots as 50% of a debate. Flat earthers don’t get to share a platform with geologists or astronomers. Lost Cause neo-Confederates, Shoa-deniers, Stalin-worshipers…they don’t get ‘equal’ time with real historians.
Or do they? If ‘on the other hand’ery is cheaper than fact-checking. If its just too aggressive to call truth true and lies lies?
Well, global warming deniers get equal time with climate scientists. Creationists are often given a platform beside evolutionary scientists – and it isn’t unusual to leave out the evolutionary scientists. Our college has classes in ghost busting, which isn’t so much whataboutery, I suppose, as the fact that the classes fill and make money for the school. (I suspect that’s part of all of it – if people want it, give it to them and pretend you’re being ‘fair and balanced’).