Shut up and laugh
Oh, good, now we’re supposed to see Sean Spicer as a funny guy and his lying for Trump as just normal business.
When opponents of the president talk about “normalizing” an abnormal administration, they are talking about the sort of thing that took place onstage Sunday night at the Emmys: Sean Spicer, Donald Trump’s first White House press secretary, showed up and made a joke about one of his false claims.
The night otherwise had been a showcase of Hollywood’s liberal leanings as applied to 2017. Stephen Colbert’s intro song and monologue sounded the alarm about global warming, Russian meddling in American politics, and police violence in cute but cutting fashion. “I’d like to vote for Selina Meyer, she’s pretty foxy,” he sang, referencing Julia Louis-Dreyfus’s Veep character. “Imagine if your president was not beloved by Nazis.”
But soon after, Colbert posed the question of how many people were watching the Emmys. The answer came in the form of Spicer’s cameo. The Republican operative wheeled out a podium like the one Melissa McCarthy used in her SNL impression of him. In a mock-stern voice, he announced: “This will be the largest audience to witness an Emmys, period, both in person and around the world!”
Isn’t that just adorable. Don’t worry, it’s all a comedy really, and in a few years everyone will look back and laugh.
CNN’s reporting also noted that the Spicer cameo was Colbert’s idea: “He and his producers knew there would be blowback. … But Colbert thought it would be funny and surprising, and that’s what mattered most.”
Well of course that’s what matters most if you see entertainment as the highest value, or the highest after money.
Last week, Spicer appeared on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, leading my colleague David Frum to write, “As former Trump staff seek to integrate themselves into American civic and business life, it will be important to evaluate which of them can be rehabilitated—and which have compromised themselves in ways that cannot be redeemed.” Already, the short-lived White House communications director Anthony Scaramucci has landed gigs co-hosting The View and TMZ on TV, where he, no doubt, can be let in on the jokes about him.
Backstage after the Emmys, Alec Baldwin was asked about the propriety of Spicer’s appearance. “Spicer obviously was compelled to do certain things that we might not have respected, that we might not have admired, that we might have been super-critical of, in order to do his job,” Baldwin replied. “But I’ve done some jobs that are things that you shouldn’t admire or respect me for either. So he and I have that in common, I suppose.” The obvious truth about that comparison is that Baldwin is an entertainer and Spicer was a public servant, held to a different standard and capable of more significant lapses. Or maybe not, as it turns out.
Springtime for Hitler, eh?
That’s the problem with entertainment in general. A lot of them have very liberal ideas, but in the end, there are 2 questions: (1) Did people applaud/laugh; and (2) Did it make money? Ethical considerations go out the window. “We’re just giving people what they want”. The question is, do we, in catering to that want, expand it? Do we further the demonization of others? Do we make the world worse? Do we lie? And if so, are we good citizens? Or is our only role to be good entertainers, and the rest of the world go hang?
So if lying is part of the job, and you are able to lie (not that people believe the lies you speak, just that you actually speak them), then you’ve done a good job. Got it.
Apparently it was Colbert’s idea. I wish that was not the case.
(Oops, and now I see that the OP has precisely that information already.)
About entertainment:
— Tony Hendra, Going Too Far (1987), p. 1, ¶ 1.