There is a very real danger that the women assaulted will disappear from view
At the New Statesman, Musa Okwonga has thoughts on how to deal with the New Year’s Eve assaults on women in Köln and Hamburg.
The volume of sexual violence against women worldwide is extraordinary: it is horrifying, heartbreaking, and finally it is enraging. Whether women are in public or in the supposed safety of their own homes, the offences committed against them are off the scale.
To quote the United Nations, “It is estimated that 35 per cent of women worldwide have experienced either physical and/or sexual intimate partner violence or sexual violence by a non-partner at some point in their lives. However, some national studies show that up to 70 per cent of women have experienced physical and/or sexual violence from an intimate partner in their lifetime“. (My italics.)
The Cologne assaults, then, did not occur in isolation, but as a particularly severe eruption of a situation which, in global terms, has always been volcanic.
He quotes from one account:
“When we came out of the station, we were very surprised by the group we met, which was made up only of foreign men…We walked through the group of men, there was a tunnel through them, we walked through…I was groped everywhere. It was a nightmare. Although we shouted and hit them, they men didn’t stop. I was horrified and I think I was touched around 100 times over the 200 metres.”
One investigator told the Kölner Express: “The female victims were so badly pushed about, they had heavy bruises on their breasts and behinds.”
Imagine how horrible that would be – being trapped, surrounded, pressed, and then groped and shoved by the people trapping you – as if you were a football, a load of laundry, a parcel of meat.
But then – the perps are not privileged people. What about that?
In the ensuing conversation, there is a very real danger that the women assaulted will disappear from view, quickly buried beneath a tug-of-words between the Right and the Left. In fact, it has already happening. So let us reiterate the facts. Scores of women were set upon by up to a thousand men in a public place. Ninety of them made complaints to police. There were also sexual assaults of a similar fashion in Hamburg on the same night. The level of entitlement that these men felt towards the bodies of their victims is appalling.
Germany, he goes on, is not particularly welcoming to people of Other races, nor does it have particularly high expectations of them.
So, what to do with all of this analysis? Well, it is actually simple. Let’s just keep sticking up for the women. As far as being a black man of African descent goes, the racists in Germany and elsewhere hate us anyway. They thought we were rapists and perverts and other assorted forms of sex attacker the second they set eyes on us. They don’t care about the women who were attacked in Cologne and Hamburg, except to prove the point that we are the animals that they always thought – or hoped – we were.
In return, I don’t care about them. Nor am I too bothered by the people who don’t want to sit next to me on the train. Fear of the unknown is a hard thing to unlearn. I am most concerned, by far, with the safety of the women who may now be more frightened than ever to enter public spaces. I don’t think that women have ever felt particularly comfortable walking through crowds of drunk and aggressive men at night, regardless of the race of those men. But groups of young men of North African and Arab origin, whatever their intentions, will most likely endure more trepidation from women than before.
So here’s what I propose we do. Why don’t we just start with the premise that it is a woman’s fundamental right, wherever she is in the world, to walk the streets and not be groped? And why don’t we see this as a perfect moment for men, regardless of our ethnic backgrounds, to get genuinely angry about the treatment of women in public spaces: to reject with fury the suggestion that we are somehow conditioned by society forever to treat women as objects, condemned by our uncontrollable sexual desires to lunge at them as they walk past?
Let’s do our best to challenge the rampant misogyny that has gone on worldwide for far too long, and reject whatever lessons of sexist repression we may have been taught. Because women are tired of telling us about this, and exhausted of fighting a battle that for too long has gone overlooked.
Thank you.
This article was originally published on the author’s blog, Okwonga.com. You can find his poetry on his website too. He tweets at @Okwonga.
Thank you. Indeed!
(I have a dream … this call to action will be the beginning of a new world.
But I’m not holding my breath.)
I just thought it needed to be said, over and over and over again. Good job.
I don’t have to imagine it. That was my middle school. Except the packs of boys who attacked me and other girls never got larger than 2 dozen at a time. And they weren’t foreigners.
That column really is amazingly powerful, isn’t it?
That’s a powerful and uplifting piece of writing. It’s good to be reminded that some men *get it*. Like Samantha Vimes, yes, I had experience of this on a small scale as a teen back in the eighties. (It *may* be less common today I hope – I have an 18 year old daughter who goes to a mixed sex school and tells me she has never experienced harassment in or out of school. And this in an area with a high Asian and Muslim population which some would suggest is a poor environment for women. Not our experience BTW…)
I’m still trying to wrap my head around the organised nature of these incidents. I don’t get it. What’s the benefit to the organisers? Are we talking something like the “purity patrols” of some Islamic countries? But Germany doesn’t have the cultural backing to support that kind of act. It seems more determined than the occasional problems we get in the UK where bored and self righteous Asian teen boys attempt the odd “purity patrol” because they’ve heard of the idea and it gives them the chance to harass a few women in the name of religion (despite what the tabloids would have you believe, it’s rarely more than that. Unpleasant and needs challenging but hardly the serious, on-going issue the Daily Mail foams at the mouth about).
Thank you for publishing this piece. The incredible irony is I just noticed Dawkins tweeted the Spectator article, “Why are feminists refusing to discuss the Cologne sex attacks?” Well, that’s news to me and all the feminist articles I’ve been reading today. Of course his fanboys used this as an excuse to pile on feminists again. Something this horrible and misogynistic happens to women in the world and Dawkins finds a way to make feminists the bad guy.
The treatment given this story omits something very important. Women were groped, grabbed and sexually assaulted, but many men were beaten up and robbed as well. I do not wish to downplay the misogyny angle in any way ( it’s very serious) but the fact men were also attacked raises some other questions. This was an extreme display of misogyny, and yet at the same time it was more than that.
Also, there were similar attacks in several other German cities, and there were reports of other attacks in places like Switzerland and Austria.
The reasons the security of women has become more precarious throughout Europe need to be addressed head on because it’s only going to get worse, much worse, if they’re not.
Here’s someone with some constructive ideas about combating this problem
http://www.dw.com/en/lale-akg%C3%BCn-muslim-migrants-need-to-accept-german-social-norms/a-18967945
@8,
Of course she’s right, but will anyone listen?
https://www.facebook.com/144310995587370/photos/a.271728576178944.71555.144310995587370/1103283723023421/?type=3&theater
@9
Of course she’s right, but will anyone listen?
Probably not. Strong, secular women of Muslim background who state simple truths about Islam are often marginalized and vilified by shallow and cowardly mainstream pundits who find such truths unpalatable and unsuitable for *polite society*.