The Bush White House “lost” 22 million emails
A tiny history lesson via Kevin Lamarque at Newsweek/Reuters.
Clinton’s email habits look positively transparent when compared with the subpoena-dodging, email-hiding, private-server-using George W. Bush administration. Between 2003 and 2009, the Bush White House “lost” 22 million emails. This correspondence included millions of emails written during the darkest period in America’s recent history, when the Bush administration was ginning up support for what turned out to be a disastrous war in Iraq with false claims that the country possessed weapons of mass destruction (WMD), and, later, when it was firing U.S. attorneys for political reasons.
Like Clinton, the Bush White House used a private email server—its was owned by the Republican National Committee. And the Bush administration failed to store its emails, as required by law, and then refused to comply with a congressional subpoena seeking some of those emails. “It’s about as amazing a double standard as you can get,” says Eric Boehlert, who works with the pro-Clinton group Media Matters. “If you look at the Bush emails, he was a sitting president, and 95 percent of his chief advisers’ emails were on a private email system set up by the RNC. Imagine if for the last year and a half we had been talking about Hillary Clinton’s emails set up on a private DNC server?”
Most troubling, researchers found a suspicious pattern in the White House email system blackouts, including periods when there were no emails available from the office of Vice President Dick Cheney. “That the vice president’s office, widely characterized as the most powerful vice president in history, should have no archived emails in its accounts for scores of days—especially days when there was discussion of whether to invade Iraq—beggared the imagination,” says Thomas Blanton, director of the Washington-based National Security Archive.
Welllll maybe there was a lot of football to watch during those days. No, maybe he had a cold. No, maybe the Internet was down. No, maybe he just did everything over the phone.
…in 2003, a whistleblower told the National Security Archive that the George W. Bush White House was no longer saving its emails. The Archive and another watchdog group, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (which had represented outed CIA agent Valerie Plame in her case against the Bush administration), refiled their original lawsuit.
The plaintiffs soon discovered that Bush aides had simply shut down the Clinton automatic email archive, and they identified the start date of the lost emails as January 1, 2003. The White House claimed it had switched to a new server and in the process was unable to maintain an archive—a claim that many found dubious.
Bush administration emails could have aided a special prosecutor’s investigation into a White House effort to discredit a diplomat who disagreed with the administration’s fabricated Iraq WMD evidence by outing his CIA agent wife, Plame. Special Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald, who was brought in to investigate that case, said in 2006 that he believed some potentially relevant emails sent by aides in Cheney’s office were in the administration’s system but he couldn’t get them.
But that’s ok because REASONS.
The supposedly lost emails also prevented Congress from fully investigating, in 2007, the politically motivated firing of nine U.S. attorneys. When the Democrat-led Senate Judiciary Committee subpoenaed related emails, Bush’s attorney general, Alberto Gonzalez, said many were inaccessible or lost on a nongovernmental private server run by the RNC and called gwb43.com. The White House, meanwhile, officially refused to comply with the congressional subpoena.
Senate Judiciary Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) called the president’s actions “Nixonian stonewalling” and at one point took to the floor in exasperation and shouted, “They say they have not been preserved. I don’t believe that!” His House counterpart, Judiciary Chairman John Conyers (D-Mich.), said Bush’s assertion of executive privilege was unprecedented and displayed “an appalling disregard for the right of the people to know what is going on in their government.”
In court in May 2008, administration lawyers contended that the White House had lost three months’ worth of email backups from the initial days of the Iraq War. Bush aides thus evaded a court-ordered deadline to describe the contents of digital backup believed to contain emails deleted in 2003 between March—when the U.S. invaded Iraq—and September. They also refused to give the NSA nonprofit any emails relating to the Iraq War, despite the PRA, blaming a system upgrade that had deleted up to 5 million emails. The plaintiffs eventually contended that the Bush administration knew about the problem in 2005 but did nothing to fix it.
One rule for them, and another rule for everyone else.
Whenever I mention to people that using a private e-mail server didn’t originate with Hillary, they start to sputter “but…but…but…Benghazi!” Or they talk about “lack of judgement” or “ethical lapses”. If many other people were doing it (and several have come out and said they were) maybe there simply wasn’t a sense that there was any ethical issues involved.
And seriously, how can anyone think in an era of Wikileaks and Edward Snowden that governmental e-mail servers are so safe? I haven’t believed that for a long time, ever since Social Security got hacked…and probably not before that.
When the Watergate burglars staged their break-in, they didn’t get much, because the papers they wanted were in a locked file cabinet, and they were caught too soon. Maybe the problem is putting stuff that should be classified in cyberspace, so easily hackable, to begin with. (And no, I’m not a Luddite. Obviously I use computers…I just have a somewhat jaded view of their ability to prevent theft).
“No, maybe he just did everything over the phone.”
Well, then subpoena the NSA. They should still have them.
This post. Exactly. What is it with people? Is everybody 15 years old and can’t remember all the way back to the early 00s? Did nobody have a job then? Does nobody remember how IT departments had their heads stuck in the mainframe 1980s? Everybody had weird kludged workarounds to avoid IT so they could get their work done. I know I did at a uni. It’s just lucky nobody cares about the evolution of obscure plants.
The Bush admin email losses actually do (and did even at the time) stand out both for the scale and how conveeeniently they lost the ones from incriminating time frames. Clinton? If the FBI studied every email I ever sent or received and there were only three out of tens of thousands marked with “(c)” in the body — and that in error for two of them apparently — I would expect some sort of Macarthur Prize for Adminstrative Precision.