Sheikha al-Jassem’s turn
In case the absurdity of Germany’s charging a comedian with insulting Erdogan isn’t enough for one day, we can turn our attention to Kuwait:
A prominent female academic and human rights activist in Kuwait has been charged with blasphemy.
Sheikha al-Jassem was summoned to the public prosecutor’s office after legal complaints were filed against her over a recent interview she gave on TV.
She asserted that the constitution of Kuwait should be above the Quran and Islamic law in governing the country.
So, you can’t win, can you – not if you think a government should be secular when you live in a theocracy. You can’t say that in a theocracy, because the theocracy defines it as “blasphemy,” and you don’t get to define it another way, because you live in a theocracy. It couldn’t be any more tightly circular. It’s exactly parallel to, in fact it’s really the same thing as, a dictator making it a crime to criticize or make fun of or tease the dictator. This is dictator-god doing the same thing, despite the fact that dictator-god doesn’t exist. Dictator-god doesn’t need to exist for this to work: the clerics and the theocratic legislators and judges will stand in for dictator-god, and act as if dictator-god did exist and did get in a tantrum when humans tried to escape his dictatorial rule. The result is the same: you cannot escape. No one can escape. You’re in a closed system and escape is forbidden.
During the interview, Ms Jassem was asked about radical Islamists who said that religion was more important than the Kuwaiti constitution.
She responded by saying that this was dangerous and that, in her opinion, politics and religion should be kept apart.
Who did the interview? IS? That looks like a trap.
Ms Jassem made reference to the violence across the Middle East and divisions between Sunni and Shia Muslims. She said that if you just went back to holy books and relied on them, society could not move forward.
Her remarks provoked a storm of attacks against her, spearheaded by Islamist members of Kuwait’s parliament.
“They were terrifying me – everywhere, not just from Kuwait, even from Saudi Arabia,” she told the BBC. “They were talking against me, they were saying bad things, they were ridiculing me. But I’m used to it now.”
Calls were made for Ms Jassem’s dismissal from Kuwait University, where she is a professor of philosophy, and a legal complaint was issued against her.
If you were thinking of going to Kuwait for a holiday, I suggest you reconsider.
The public prosecutor told her that the complainant said he had been psychologically damaged by her remarks.
But Allah is all-powerful. Why be psychologically damaged by such things when Allah is all-powerful? Why not just trust that Allah will see to it that everything is really all right, whatever the appearances may be?
I don’t want to trivialize the horror of what’s happening in Kuwait, but I can’t help noticing that there’s a lot of that going around. “That” being people claiming to be psychologically damaged by others’ remarks and feeling that that justifies shutting down certain kinds of speech and abusing certain speakers.
Theocracies and dictatorships take the tendency to its logical conclusion.
And what makes that even more irritating is that of course there are ways people can do psychological damage by saying things. Bullying and harassment can be verbal as well as (or rather than) physical. I was going to say something directly about the absurdity of the claim but then would have had to say something about the reality of real verbal bullying, so I decided to skip both – and that too is annoying, because it lets people like the jackass complainant off the hook.
Yes, and verbal harassment can have the same effect–inhibiting speech.
Sticky wicket.
If someone suggesting there should be laws that are independent of religion upsets a person that much, they were already psychologically damaged… by their religion.
That we sent our young men and women to die to defend this place now seems preposterous. And we bring Kuwait’s corrupt Sheiks to America so that our hospitals and clinics and medical personnel can treat their obesity, their gout and their alcohol ravaged livers.