No visible injuries or signs of violence
Naz Shah is accusing the Pakistani authorities of trying to cover up the murder of Samia Shahid.
Pakistani police investigating the death told the Guardian on Sunday that there were “no visible injuries or signs of violence” on Shahid’s body when it was found last Wednesday in the family home in Pandori, Jhelum, 50 miles (80km) south of Islamabad.
A postmortem report released on Thursday shows that her body did in fact have a “reddish brown linear horizontal bruise measuring about 19cm extending from just below [the] right ear and around the neck”.
The Guardian has seen photographs of Shahid’s body, which appear to confirm the finding. There also appear to be two purple welts around her neck. Naz Shah, Shahid’s MP in Bradford West, has accused Pakistani authorities of a potential cover-up in light of the findings.
She said on Thursday: “I originally intervened in this case to demand that there was a proper investigation into my constituent’s death, saying it had all the hallmarks of a so-called ‘honour’ killing. Having seen the autopsy report, I think we are now also looking at a case involving a potential cover-up.”
It has to do with that huge bruise on her neck that the police did not mention to the Guardian on Sunday, and the two welts on her neck ditto.
“I have asked for the police officer and the physician who did the first postmortem to be investigated,” the MP said. “Just a few days ago they were telling us the autopsy was inconclusive and that there were no visible signs on her body and now the autopsy report shows that there were marks on her neck.”
Oh those.
Shahid’s family have said variously that she died of a heart attack or an asthma attack and insist they did not kill her.
It was a wasp sting! No, she fell down the stairs by accident. No, she choked on an apple. No, she held her breath out of spite.
The family insist Shahid was married to Shakeel, a first cousin, and police in Pakistan say they have not received any documents proving otherwise.
In fact, she divorced him in a UK sharia court in 2014 and then married Kazam at Leeds town hall in September 2014, after converting to Shia Islam, while her family is Sunni.
Friends of Shahid in the UK said the family felt so dishonoured by her behaviour that they did not acknowledge she had remarried.
A family member in Bradford was given a harassment warning by police in September 2015 when Shahid, who was living in Dubai, returned to the UK to try to patch things up with her family, West Yorkshire police said.
Two people, believed to be cousins of Shahid, were arrested in Bradford this week on suspicion of threatening Shah. Both were bailed on Wednesday night pending further investigations.
A nasty, nasty business.
No, all of the above. Out of spite. By accident. Because “honour”?
Obviously, her own neck murdered her. Case closed.
She strangled herself, in the study, with a wrench.
What a load of utter tosh.
Maybe it is at least a good thing that they didn’t feel safe acknowledging it as an “honor” murder?
I’m sitting here, looking at a ruler, measuring 19cm. That is a big bruise. If it’s around the front of the neck, then it must be right across her throat. Shah is right to suspect a cover-up. There’s no way the police could have just overlooked something like that.
So basically an incredibly blatant strangulation bruise. And yes I agree with Samantha Vimes in that even though honour killings are a known institution in these some nations, the fact that they are trying to hide this one I think shows they are beginning to feel the pressure of western condemnation of this practice. It’s small, but it still appears to be the early stages of progress.
Hmm. I’m not sure it makes sense to cite the pressure of western condemnation of this practice on its own – what about domestic condemnation of this practice? It does exist, even if it is partially repressed by violence and threats of violence.
If any women from Muslim countries or neighborhoods are reading this:
DON’T
‘…try to patch things up with …family,’ without adequate security.