A street named Qadir
Sadly, poignantly, indeed tragically, Aatish Taseer sees things more clearly than his father did.
Pakistan was part of his faith, and one of the reasons for the differences that arose between us in the last years of his life–and there were many–was that this faith never allowed him to accept what had become of the country his forefathers had fought for.
…
And where my father and I would have parted ways in the past was that I believe Pakistan and its founding in faith, that first throb of a nation made for religion by people who thought naively that they would restrict its role exclusively to the country’s founding, was responsible for producing my father’s killer.
For if it is science and rationality whose fruit you wish to see appear in your country, then it is those things that you must enshrine at its heart; otherwise, for as long as it is faith, the men who say that Pakistan was made for Islam, and that more Islam is the solution, will always have the force of an ugly logic on their side. And better men, men like my father, will be reduced to picking their way around the bearded men, the men with one vision that can admit no other, the men who look to the sanctities of only one Book.
Exactly. Better men and women will be wiped out by the bearded men, until there is nothing left but bearded men and their terrorized slaves.
Already, even before his body is cold, those same men of faith in Pakistan have banned good Muslims from mourning my father; clerics refused to perform his last rites; and the armoured vehicle conveying his assassin to the courthouse was mobbed with cheering crowds and showered with rose petals.
I should say too that on Friday every mosque in the country condoned the killer’s actions; 2,500 lawyers came forward to take on his defence for free; and the Chief Minister of Punjab, who did not attend the funeral, is yet to offer his condolences in person to my family who sit besieged in their house in Lahore.
And so, though I believe, as deeply as I have ever believed anything, that my father joins that sad procession of martyrs – every day a thinner line – standing between him and his country’s descent into fear and nihilism, I also know that unless Pakistan finds a way to turn its back on Islam in the public sphere, the memory of the late governor of Punjab will fade.
And where one day there might have been a street named after him, there will be one named after Malik Mumtaz Qadir, my father’s boy-assassin.
As Salman Rushdie said a couple of days ago – RIP Pakistan.
This is depressing, somehow. The founders of my country tried that, and it still remains a constant struggle.
Wow. Insightful. Clear. How can one be so when hell is going on around him and having lost someone I presume to be dear to him? Must be something a public figure (and family) in Pakistan grow used to.
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Rational Humanist, Dennis Hunter. Dennis Hunter said: RT @OpheliaBenson: A street named Qadir http://dlvr.it/CxfVv […]
Yes, it is unfortunate that Pakistan was created as an essentially one-religion state. India next door has a more tolerant and liberal society because of its plurality of religions, and they all have to coexist as peacefuly as possible.
Taneer’s assassin, a bearded zombie clearly pretty pleased with himself and basking in overnight local celebrity status, is almost certainly unaware of the immense damage he has done to his country.
Who in their right mind would go there, or invest a single dollar there given the way the country is spiralling into the abyss?
http://www.allvoices.com/contributed-news/7817852-pakistan-salman-taseers-killer-confirmed-that-malik-mumtaz-qadri-has-not-been-tortured
The RIP Pakistan was done years ago by most Indians
Sadly , it gets worse rather than gets better.
No condemnation from any “liberal” muslims anywhere, that I have seen or read. Mainstream muslims must come to realize that if they persist in supinely accepting vile crimes carried out in their name then they are just as much a part of the problem as the extremists are.
Sailor,
Just because it isn’t reported doesn’t mean there sre no voices. This is from Egypt rather than Pakistan, but it still gives me some hope.
http://english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent/1/0/3365/Egypt/0/Egypts-Muslims-attend-Coptic-Christmas-mass,-servi.aspx
sailor, look a bit harder. Tarek Fatah for one has been energetic in his condemnation.
An astonishingly honest, brave and clear statement of all that is wrong with Pakistan, or any social system that puts religion at the heart of its self-conception. It makes his book <i>Stranger to History</i> one that should be on our reading lists. Anyone who can so boldly differ with his father in the way that he does about the place of religious faith in public life is someone to whom we have to listen.
Even Inayat Bunglawala seems to be coming to his senses.
http://inayatscorner.wordpress.com/2011/01/08/pakistan-the-moral-collapse-of-a-nation/
And on CiF, Kamila Shamsie and Sana Saleem in particular produced good articles.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/belief/2011/jan/05/salman-taseer-murder-pakistan
But the Guardian had to spoil it all by having Imran Khan, a rather nasty man who supports the blasphemy law and sharia, spout the usual apologetics.
Amira Nowaira did well on the coptic attack in Egypt, also on CiF
Yes, Inayat Bunglawalla (his last name has strange connotations for me, since a wallah is someone who sells or does something — a chai wallah is someone who sells chai — is a buglawalla someone who bungles a lot?! I always think of this when I see his name!) seems to be talking some sense at last:
Will he stick to this, I wonder, or will we be hearing more theocratic nonsense come from this source as we have in the past?
With Bungles, one never knows Eric. But he seems to be on a very, slow learning curve and may make it to the light afterall. I always assumed that his surname origin was “that bloke who lives in the bungalow”. Bungalow itself is an indian word.
sailor, look a bit harder. Tarek Fatah for one has been energetic in his condemnation.
Yes brave Tarek soldiers on virtually alone.
In the meantime, thousands of Pakistani lawyers have offered their services to Taseer’s killer free of charge.
The right time to have spoken up against Pakistan’s blasphemy laws occured more than 30 years ago. It ‘s way too late to do anything about it now.
Bhutto was assasinated by islamists just over three years ago. According to some sources, turns out that the jokers who killed her belonged to an islamist group she’d helped set up and finance…to kill and drive out Hindus from Indian Kashmir. I once watched an interview with her where, in a condescending tone, she repeatedly refered to India as the non-descript ‘our neighbour’. She was far too supremacist and islamo-arrogant to bring herself to even pronounce the word “India”. One had the impression that this secular moderate hated ‘our neighbour’ ten times more than she loved Pakistan.
I can’t really care what hapens to the place. Even the country’s “secularists” are responsable for cooking up the current Islamist stew, and if they end up having to eat it, then just whose fault is that?
All I care about is getting the nukes out of the place. Once that’s done, if Sunnis and Shias, Pashtuns and Balouchis want to joyously kill each other off in the name of ‘prophet’, then let them do so.
Even international aid agencies have pretty much given up on the place, as evidenced by their tepid reaction following recent floods.
What can I say?
The place is becoming hell on earth.
Thanks Ophelia – I see what you mean. There is much more condemnation within Pakistan itself than you would know from our media. Some brave people speaking out. Many of the comments on Pakistani news sites and blogs are chilling though!
Eric, yes, I want to read whatever I can find by Aatish Taseer. When I posted the link on Salman Rushdie’s Facebook page yesterday he told me he has A.T.’s first novel beside him on the desk.
Kamila Shamsie was joking with him (mostly in Urdu) yesterday; I’ll have to find her CisF piece.
Sonia…I was chilled by what A.T. said about his father keeping him and his mother at arm’s length because he couldn’t be in politics with an Indian wife and half-Indian child. God how awful.
Pakistan now has to accomplish a very improbable feat. The Governor of Punjab has been murdered, the killer is popularly feted as a hero, and his victim widely reviled.
It is likely in my view that the Pakistani legal system will give the killer, <!– @page { size: 8.5in 11in; margin: 0.79in } P { margin-bottom: 0.08in } –>Malik Mumtaz Qadir, at most a rap over the knuckles, and will endorse the idea that anyone who murders in the cause of Islam is a hero, and automatically above the law. One can murder even a high official one considers has offended Islam and ride a wave of popular, clerical and legal approval straight out of the jail.
No country can possibly operate on such a basis.
My apologies for the extraneous stuff inadvertently pasted in with the rest of my last comment.
Shit happens.
to sailor 1031…
A squeak out of a liberal muslim in pakistan and he will be found decapitated or hung, or shot like a stray dog! (take your pick). we the moderates utter a word and it could be concocted into a form of blasphemy! better to save your skin, then to be gutted like a lamb!
That, is mostly, what is preventing the moderates….fear of life..
This is a country that has gone to the dogs…the bearded ones….
Well, talk to us when you can, Kamal.