Inverted Colonialism
Consider Azam Kamguian in Ibn Warraq’s Leaving Islam, for instance. Page 216.
The very fact that people are forced to abide by laws based on something some god or prophet is reported to have said somewhere is a form of mental violence.
Page 219.
When I came to the West in the early 1990s, I was faced with the fact that the majority of intellectuals, mainstream media, academics, and feminists, in the name of respecting ‘other cultures,’ were trying to justify Islam by dividing it into fundamentalist and moderate, progressive and reactionary…For people like me, the victims of Islam in power, it was suffocating to listen to and have to refute endless tales to justify the terror and bloodshed committed by Islamic movements and Islamic governments in Iran and in the region.
She was tortured in Iran, while verses from the Koran were played in the torture chambers.
Western liberal and left-wing intellectuals have a strong sense of guilt about the West’s past colonial history and are apologetic to the Third World as such. They consider the Third World a given entity, where people are keen to suffer under the rotten rule of Islam, are happy to be deprived of the human civilization in the twenty-first century. To them, women desire sexual apartheid, girls love to be segregated, people hate civil rights and individual freedom in the Third World.
She calls that ‘inverted colonialism.’ One wonders if it’s also inverted colonialism that is causing all this communalism, this insistent shoving of people into certain communities and keeping them out of others, by labeling them as ‘members’ of some and not of others. One wonders, and one wishes people would notice what they are doing, and stop.
Good post. Thought provoking
Did you read Amartya Sen’s piece in The New Republic?
Thanks. I linked to Sen’s piece in News, and I’ve read parts but not all of it yet. Going to though, along with Nagel’s review of Appiah, and quote highlights – they’re both very interesting.
Interesting comment. I think you’re on the right track with “inverted colonialism” causing communalism.Maybe it’s a stretch but it seems to be on a par somewhat with what the European administrators did in colonial Africa – favoring one ethnic, religious, or tribal group over another (as civil servants, for example).
“…one wishes people would notice what they are doing, and stop.”
Good point – it seems to be such an ingrained, unconcious habit for so many these days.