Cool, They All Melted!
I can’t resist adding another example – because it seems to me to be so grotesque. It’s from a column by Nicholas Kristof, whom Brian Leiter calls ‘one of the leading “no ideas and the ability to express them” columnists at the New York Times.’ (How convenient to happen on that description just after I read the Kristof column. Doncha just love it when things fall into your lap like that? Serendipity?) The column is a brief look at one of the Rapture books, a phenomenon I’ve talked about here more than once. It starts with a pretty passage:
Jesus merely raised one hand a few inches and a yawning chasm opened in the earth, stretching far and wide enough to swallow all of them. They tumbled in, howling and screeching, but their wailing was soon quashed and all was silent when the earth closed itself again.
Then there’s a bit more:
In Glorious Appearing, Jesus merely speaks and the bodies of the enemy are ripped open. Christians have to drive carefully to avoid “hitting splayed and filleted bodies of men and women and horses. The riders not thrown,” the novel says, “leaped from their horses and tried to control them with the reins, but even as they struggled, their own flesh dissolved, their eyes melted and their tongues disintegrated. Seconds later the same plague afflicted the horses, their flesh and eyes and tongues melting away, leaving grotesque skeletons standing, before they too rattled to the pavement.”
Nice, right? The kind of thing one feels really pleased to know that other people are reading and enjoying. Yes indeed. Kristof is critical, to be sure, but…note what he also says:
I had reservations about writing this column because I don’t want to mock anyone’s religious beliefs, and millions of Americans think Glorious Appearing describes God’s will.
Pardon me for a moment while I let fly with a stream of oaths. I mean, really! This is where this kind of thinking gets you. Millions of people think that kind of shit is God’s will – and we don’t want to mock them, or alternatively point out that it’s completely disgusting to believe and relish that? I hasten to point out that he does come down on the right side immediately after saying that – ‘Yet ultimately I think it’s a mistake to treat religion as a taboo, either in this country or in Saudi Arabia.’ – but why say it at all? Maybe the Times told him to say it – in which case my oaths are directed at the paper, not the individual. I don’t care which it is; the point is the deed, the thought and the expression of it, not who did it. Millions of people think the Rapture books describe God’s will. So what? So what, so what, so what? If they think that, and enjoy the thought, there is something hideously wrong with them, and no one should have a fraction of a second’s inhibition about saying so as loudly as possible.
You know what? I really hate knowing that millions of my fellow Americans read and enjoy that stuff. The god-bothering is bad enough, but then when the god-bothering combines with that kind of slavering lust for other people’s torture and instant elimination – it’s beyond a joke. It’s al Qaeda-ish, and it’s disgusting.
It’s odd, the Rapture series is one of the very first things I wrote about for N&C. Because there happened to be an interview with one of the ‘authors’ on ‘Fresh Air,’ so I commented on it.
And speaking of comments, I am going to do the Ten Books list. I haven’t forgotten. Things have been busy.
And just think that there are whole swathes of Christians who believe that the godless are going to suffer *eternal* torment, and yet they still worship their god.
It starts with the fairy tales where the “good” king skins unsuccessful suitors and throws them in a snake pit, and the wicked stepmother is rolled away in a barrelful of nails. Then there’s the tv cartoons where the coyote or cat gets pulverized daily. Then, move up to violent movies, books, you name it; you are not even free of it if you hit the “erotica” shelf, don’t get me started on that…Humans are sick, morbid @#$%^&*’s, that’s what it is. I should say, a lot of them are, and so this crap you adduce is “normal”. It isn’t just this culture either, from what I recall. You and I seem to have outgrown it.
Violence is just so gross [and I’ll flatten anyone who disagrees…]
Good ol’ Thomas Aquinas in “Summa Theologica” mentions that one of the agreeable pleasures of heaven is getting to watch your enemies suffer in hell.
Watching coyotes crushed on TV is hardly necessary to incubate this sort of sadism.
I can totally relate. My in-laws are also avid and gleeful consumers of that sort of garbage and noisily declare themselves guardians of morality, all the time while gloating over the punishment that their god has prepared for unbelievers. No matter how hard you try, these people are far beyond any attempt to engage in rational conversation, and it’s extremely scary that their fanatical views command the attention of such a big sector of the American populace. Between them and the crazed Islamic fundamentalists the prospects for the XXI century can hardly be any worse.
Good comment on Kristof, also. His feeble half-criticisms half-apologies of organized religion do nothing else than provoke my disdain. Apparently his columns are geared towards obtaining everybody’s approval.
“Thank God” I am an atheist. Now with (I hope)the sympathy of my fellow rationalists, I’ll go hide in my cave until fundamentalists of all stripes have blown each other to pieces.
I know, about the eternal punishment and the gloating over it. (A very amusing guy I used to work with at the zoo made it a practice to interrogate believers about that.)
And yet religion is supposed to make people morally better. Hmmm.
Excellent commentary! It is indeed quite bizarre one is asked “not to mock” people who fantasize about torturing the better part of the world population to death. Far as I am concerned, sick stuff like that deserves a reaction considerably stronger than mockery.
Of course I agree with the sentiments. My comment is rather more obscure.
Is your use of the phrase “So What? So what, so what, so what?” a tell-tale sign of exposure to the Anti Nowhere League?
Nope. Never hoid of it.
No, that was just a kind of yell of rage.
Must be a case of convergent verbal evolution, then and obviously an argument for Intelligent Design.
Which leads me on to another question – does B&W have Simon Conway Morris in its sights?
Must admit that I’ve never really thought Ophelia likely to be an aficionado of punk rock!
Oh yeah?? Well that’s all you know! I have a spike through my head even as we speak.